Good grief. You make it sound like he's just blasting Rihanna for sport. It was on Watch What Happens Live during their "Plead the Fifth" segment. Andy asks celebs 3 questions and they can only plead the fifth to one question, so they have to answer these questions because they don't know how bad that 3rd question will be. They asked him what popular singer today would not make it in American Idol. He said Rihanna because she has some pitch issues. Have you heard her sing live? He's 100% correct! But don't make him out to be bashing her. If it wasn't her, he would have had to say someone else's name. Don't make a story where there isn't one.

I'm surprised he would say that, I think she has quite a few fans that would disagree. Btw, Clay, would have YOU done lately?

Pitch problems? What the hell Clay Aiken? I think her voice has grown over the years. Her voice is pretty.