Melanie Amaro Covers "Man in the Mirror" on The X Factor

by at . Comments

Give Melanie Amaro credit: The X Factor front-runner is unafraid to tackle history's most iconic artist.

For the second time this season, the aspiring singer belted out a Michael Jackson cover, following last month's "Will You Be There?" with last night's "Man in the Mirror." How did she fare?

Simon Cowell found his protege to be "bloody fantastic," though L.A. Reid was a bit more pointed in his critique. He praised Melanie's voice, but referred to the song itself as not "that inventive." Watch the rendition now and then sound off: is Amaro still the favorite? Or is Rachel Crow making major progress?

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

More From The Hollywood Gossip

X-factor-season-3-judges

Fox Cancels The X Factor

The X Factor has been canceled by Fox. Will you miss it?
Alex-and-sierra-say-something

Alex and Sierra Win The X Factor: Their Top Performances

Alex and Sierra are your X Factor champions. Relive some of their best performances here.
Demi-lovato-drinks-annoying-juice

The X Factor Mocks Demi Lovato: Fair or Foul?

Demi Lovato was aghast at a skit on The X Factor last night. Did she have a right to be?
The-x-factor-season-three-finalists

The X Factor Winner: Who Came Out on Top?

The X Factor crowned its Season 3 winner tonight. Did the right act come out on top?

Avatar

Melanie has nailed it every week - she amazes me. I like Rachel, but I prefer her as a kid.