If I feel like watching "put down" commentary I will watch Fox News Channel. Please don't turn DWTS into that. Judges personal derogatory comments are not needed

MAX HIT ON THE NOSE!!! IF HE HAD NICOLE, JENNIFER AND RICKI AS PARTNERS MAX WOULD HAVE WON TOO!!! SIMPLE.. THESE WOMEN HAS HAD DANCE BACKGROUND IN THEM.. HELLLLOOOO!!!

I'd also like to point out that Derek has absolutely NOT got nothing but praise. He suffered a very similar meltdown to the one Maks just had with Shannon Elizabeth. Also, even in the case of Nicole, let's not forget his infamous Quickstep that earned a 6 from Len!

The comparisons with Derek don't really make any sense. Maks said that Derek got all these amazing partners, but this really isn't the case aside from Nicole. Brooke, for example, was a model. Up until that point, models had the worst track record on the show, usually getting booted in the first 2 weeks. Jennifer Grey was 50 something years old! And Ricki is overweight! I would counter that the partners Maks got, at least on paper, have been even better that what Derek has gotten. Derek got Nicole, Maks got Mel B. Derek got Ricki, Maks got Kirstie. Derek got Brooke, Maks got Erin Andrews. And now Maks has Hope. On paper at least, athletes usually do extremely well, and have taken the Mirrorball on many occasions. Ultimately, how everything turns out in the end is more about the teaching of the professional. Derek is turning the overweight Ricki Lake into a sensation. Whereas Maks is unfortuantely wasting the athletic potential of Hope.

I dont believe the Judges should compare them to animals or be disrespectful to the stars or dancers. However, Hope is not doing her best and if she thinks she is, then maybe she should leave. She didn't have any hip action and her feet did not land on point, but thats what the judges should have said and let it go at that. In my opinion both parties was wrong in their comments, they should both apologize to each other.