Who Should Win American Idol?

by at . Comments

The rocker is out, and three remain.

As American Idol heads into the final run of season 10, taking us to the hometowns of its remaining contestants next week, three distinct singers remain.

Idol Final Three
  1. Scotty McCreery: The all-American boy, seemingly came out of the womb with the perfect voice for country music. As consistent as any performer this season, but also as predictable.
  2. Lauren Alaina: Carrie Underwood, 2.0? A similar look and sound to the season four champion. An early favorite who has built up momentum each week.
  3. Haley Reinhart: The clear underdog. Has openly battled with judges, notably Randy Jackson, who have been critical of her recent renditions. Viewers have come to embrace her fighting attitude.

So, who will it be? Who should it be?

Tags: , , ,
Avatar

Haley should win!! She has the best voice and the most range. I think she'll make a great asset to the franchise.

Avatar

Unbelievable that James got voted off!! Something went seriously wrong somewhere! Scotty is SO predictable and boring!

Avatar

haley hands down is the best singer no comparison.. lauren is second scotty should have left along time ago

Avatar

James Durbin didn't win probably because he's a version of Adam Lambert. But don't get me wrong, he's a great performer. JAMES' FANS SHOULD LEARN TO GET OVER. sore losers. pfft

Avatar

Scotty...there's just no one like him in our generation. He does not need to scream or growl, his range is beautiful as it is. It gives me goosebumps whenever he sings a beautiful melody, it's very SWEET. JAMES' FANS SHOULD STOP BEING A POOR LOSER. Aren't they being unfair telling their bet is the only who deserve to be on the top? When all of the idol contestants worked their butts off to get to where they are right now??

Avatar

James Durbin you're our WINNER and Pia is #2....A I should correct their mistake and the phone glitch, by having James back, and sending two home this week.... I think if you read all the comments, if nothing is done to correct the error,A I will have lost a great following............ No way James got voted off..

Avatar

A I had a glitch in their phones,and some of the votes went to Haley, You should bring James Back and send two home next week. but if A I chooses not to correct their error, you will have lost a lot of Loyal followers, But James Durbin you are a WINNER and Pia is second to the real fans.LOL from a 68 year old who hasen't enjoyed myself so much as to waiting each week to see you and Pia, can't wait for your first CD.

Avatar

The voting had a glitch, in no way did James Durbin get voted off. A I should bring him back, and do a correct vote, it was the shows fault for the voting error, and they should make it right.. even if A I doesn't re do the vote.. James Durbin you are our WINNER and Pia is second...

Avatar

I am so thrilled that Haley, Lauren & Scotty are the top 3. They've been my favorites since the top 13. I couldn't be happier. I kind of hope Haley wins. I love her voice, the way she performs, her look (she's adorable) & her personality (she's so nice & always happy & positive). I'll even be happy if Lauren or Scotty win. They're both so nice & have great voices & personalities as well. Good luck to all 3 of you. You're all fantastic!

Avatar

JAME'S IS GONE SO I DON'T REALLY CARE...I WON'T BE WATCHING AMERICAN IDOL BECAUSE THEY OBVIOUSLY DO NOT RECONGNIZE WHEN THERE COULD BE A PROBLEM WITH THE VOTE'S. SUCH AS PHONES, ETC.

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]