Haley Reinhart Has a Moment on American Idol

by at . Comments

Haley Reinhart had a moment on American Idol last night.

That's what Randy Jackson said about the finalist's cover of "I Who Have Nothing." Haley was joined on stage by a string section and responded perfectly to Lady GaGa's advice to give fans "drama."

Reinhart surely did, as J. Lo deemed it "one of the best performances of the year."

Prior to this incredible rendition, Haley delivered a somewhat shaky version of Michael Jackson's "Earth Song." The judges questioned her song choice and we've posted a video of it below for readers to sound off on. Enjoy!

Tags: ,
Avatar

If Haley couldn't sing she wouldn't have made it this far, everybody keeps bashing Haley, just read all the comments directed to her, good or bad. America stop hating and embrace your next American Idol, HALEY REINHART!!!

Avatar

Haley can't sing - all she does is scream. She should have been sent home ...

Avatar

Haley has one really good song and she is still there what is wrong with voters?? is it her figure and outfits?? come on america she can't sing that well, let her go home.

Christine-lemm

Hmmmm Seems she can sing a whole lot better then most here can spell!

Avatar

HALEY YOU DO SUX!!!!!! YOU REALLY NEED TO GO HOME YOU DONT DESERVE ANYTHING!!! OTHERS WERE SOO MUCH MORE TALENTED THAN YOU. DUDES QUIT VOTING FOR HER TO SEE WHAT SHE IS GONNA WEAR, SHE NOT EVEN CUTE. STOP VOTING FOR HER AND GIVE SOMEONE WITH TALENT A CHANCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Avatar

i'd like to see scotty win. but i really don't care. i lost interest when they sent paul home.

Avatar

Haley SUCKS!!!!!!!! The only reason she is till there is because Caseys followers are now supporting his GF. Casey actually had talent! Too bad it wasn't the other way...talent stayed and off key grawl girl who sux went home. Sorry Casey u got robbed!!!!!!!!!!!!! OF THE THREE LEFT. ALL WILL GO FAR! But Go LAUREN!!!!!!

Avatar

Haley has been in this competition because America loves her singing and her all-in-one only perfect voiced performer.
The brainwashable minority is always complaining and taking judges and others powers as granted.
Obama says Obey, Randy says Wrong - you say "I Obey and the song was wrong". It's called Patriot Act, not patriotism which is full of war, rape, lies and destroy for da Cristians :)
Ho Haley - home or not, you did YOU: just as Randy told 10 shows before, lol...

Avatar

Who ever I was jealous of Haley, dont get mad because im telling the truth. Haley cant sing, she been gone home@ the judges tell her the truth cant sing now you jealous@ go home Haley!!

Avatar

OMG Haley was AWESOME!!!!! She did that song justice.........her voice is AMAZING......I absolutely think she can win American Idol!!!! GO HALEY!!!!

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]
x Close Ad