Haley is a phenomenal singer, a throwback to a time when singing meant something. My hope is that she will someday do a Judy Garland song -- "Smile", for example. She has infectious charm, and that, more than her vocal power and range, is what speaks to my heart.
The voting system at American Idol is ridiculously dysfunctional. More often than not, the poor singers are the ones who advance. So yes, it IS shocking when a brilliant singer with intelligence and artistic integrity reaches the final three.
James is a good singer and proformer but metal has pretty well gone to the past as he said.
The final run off will be Scotty and Laurn unless someone holds Laurn's age against her.
I couldn't believe that James was kicked off. He should have won. America has officially pulled yet another "Daughtry" and sent the best home. But, like Chris, I have no doubt he'll still go far. He has way too much talent to let him slip back through the cracks of obscurity.
I cant believe James is gone. James you can go far with your voice. Hopefuly Scotty can take it. The girls are not in to win it. Thats all I have to say.
Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.
Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]
Comments (122 Total)
It is obvious who the producers want to have in the Finale... Hopefully the girl will be Haley... Gifted & Raw talent. The other two are so boring.
Haley is a phenomenal singer, a throwback to a time when singing meant something. My hope is that she will someday do a Judy Garland song -- "Smile", for example. She has infectious charm, and that, more than her vocal power and range, is what speaks to my heart. The voting system at American Idol is ridiculously dysfunctional. More often than not, the poor singers are the ones who advance. So yes, it IS shocking when a brilliant singer with intelligence and artistic integrity reaches the final three.
James is a good singer and proformer but metal has pretty well gone to the past as he said. The final run off will be Scotty and Laurn unless someone holds Laurn's age against her.
I couldn't believe that James was kicked off. He should have won. America has officially pulled yet another "Daughtry" and sent the best home. But, like Chris, I have no doubt he'll still go far. He has way too much talent to let him slip back through the cracks of obscurity.
I cant believe James is gone. James you can go far with your voice. Hopefuly Scotty can take it. The girls are not in to win it. Thats all I have to say.