Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald: On the American Idol Chopping Block?

by at . Comments

It's not that Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald are bad singers, but their efforts have lagged behind the rest of the field at times on American Idol.

Did the twosome do enough to turn things around last night? Or are both in big trouble when the votes are tallied on tonight's elimination episode?

Stefano elected to sing "When a Man Loves a Woman," Percy Sledge-style, while Paul went on with Johnny Cash's "Folsom Prison Blues." Thoughts?

Watch their performances from Wednesday night below and tell us if you think either - or neither - should be receiving a ticket home this evening ...

Tags: , ,
Like Us On Facebook

More From The Hollywood Gossip

American-idol-season-13-judges

American Idol Season 14: Who's Coming Back?

We have major American Idol Season 14 news. Read on to learn who will be returning.
Caleb-johnson-and-jena-irene-prom-pic

Caleb Johnson Takes Jena Irene to the Prom!

Caleb Johnson and Jena Irene as prom dates? Does it get any cuter than this?!?
Caleb-johnson-and-jena-irene-duet

American Idol Finale: All the Performances!

American Idol crowned a winner last night. It also featured very many performances.
Jena-and-caleb

American Idol Results: Who Won Season 13?

The American Idol results are in! Did Caleb Johnson or Jena Irene win Season 13?

Avatar

forget the male or female thing, forget the looks, forget the judges. IS THIS A SINGING COMPETITION OR NOT? Pia was the best voice in the show, she will get a recording contract, she will go farther then any of the other competitors in real life. She won't be subject to the Tiny Boppers votes when they vote for everything except the singing voice. I agree that style and stage presence has as much to do with success as the voice, but you can learn them you have to have the voice or it does'nt matter how pretty you are.
My Opinion

Avatar

It's way to-bad the judges used there save already, because Pia was definetly one of the, or the best singer of them all!!! Watch her in the future she'll get a recording contract,forsure.People got tired of her jump suits and then she sang a song that young voters were not familure with? It is a teeny-bop show, now that we don't have any judges that can say anything negitve its not allowed!!! Bad for the rating's!!!!!bla, bla bla !!!

Avatar

All three of the judges are all a joke !!!THERE ALL SO AFRAID TO SAY SOMETHING NEGITIVE, THERE ALL WEEKS**KS, THERE AFRAID THE CROUD WILL BOO THEM AND NOT LIKE THEM!!!COME-ON, WAS SIMON THE ONLY ONE WITH A BACKBONE!!! I'm SO SICK OF HEARING J-LO SAYING HOW WONDERFUL AND GREAT THEY ALL ARE? AFTER EACH PERFORMANCE, SHE AND STEVEN HAVE ABSOLUTLY NATHING ILL TO SAY? AT LEAST SIMON WAS HONEST!!!!! ONE MORE WEAK OF THIS HAPPY GO LUCKY CRAP ME AND MY FRIENDS AND EMPLOYERS ARE DONE WITH THIS PANZY-PATTY-CAKE SHOW!

Avatar

Wow Marc..You hit the nail on the head with your guess of the bottom three. I am DISGUSTED that Paul is still on. He's messed lyrics up, disrespected all Marines with his jacket he wore, and SLAUGHTERED a Johnny Cash song. Yeah, the guy has a great smile but this is a singing competition. Key word: SINGING. If it was up to me, Paul, Jacob and Stefano would be the next 3 eliminated. I just hope the smart half of America feels the same way.

Avatar

WTF......are theese people voting off there rockers or deaf,cause i think pia does a great job all the time shes actually one that can sing. There all good but really america.

Madrealacron

I Love Paul McDonald! I get tired of hearing people always trying to sound the same. He has his own style and I love it! This is how music evolves and changes, by peole like paul who does his own thing and stops trying to sound like all the past contestants.
I LOVE YOU PAUL, DONT LISTEN TO ALL THE HATERS!!!

Avatar

Paul is going to make it all the way through he is so amazing i love him hes my insparation everybody who hates him is a retard and needs to get their hering checked and stefano is my baby boy nobody can mess with my baby... Paul is my hero i love them both

Avatar

if you look at Stefano's wikipedia it already says that he is eliminated this week.

Avatar

Hahaha all I can say is if Paul only has a 3 note range then Scotty only has a 2 note range ;)

Avatar

Percy Sledge is a great choice. Sledge became one of the first artists to introduce the world to the Muscle Shoals Sound with his release of “When a Man Loves a Woman� in 1966. Sledge was inspired to write the song when his girlfriend left him and moved to Los Angeles. On my Rockaeology blog at http://bit.ly/g393rm I tell how Sledge worked as a hospital orderly, singing in the halls during his shift, when he recorded the track. It was his first time in a recording studio.