18 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

Robel -- you're too "idiot", but I'd still vote for you if you were creative and put on a great show.

Avatar

Another very talented musician, vocalist, etc. voted off because America seems to go for the safe, boring, mainstream performers that we already have too much of. Casey will most likely have a gre
at career due to his talent, much like many other fabulously talented non-winners on American Idol....... Jacob??????? Seriously an American Idol??????????????????????

Avatar

I LOVE SCOTTY,I THINK THE SINGERS SHOULD BE ABLE TO SING WHAT THEY DO BEST SCOTTY IS COUNTRY,JACOB IS GOSSBLE,AND JAMES IS ROCK AN ROLL,AND THE GIRLS ARE WHAT THAY LIKE,OH HI RANDY HI JEN,AND STEVE YOUR FINE ANY WAY,LOVE YOU ALL,I USED TO WRITE MUSIC BUT I;M 51 KNOWN AN I KNOW A LITTLE BIT ABOUT MUSIC,PAUL AND PIA WAS GREAT PEOPLE, BIG FAN SISSY S.

Avatar

Idol must be fudging the votes again. Jacob should of gone home 3 weeks ago. It's not about the best, it's about "image" let's face it.

Avatar

America doesn't know real talent. These teeny-boppers voting thousands if times is not fair! Every phone number/ email should get just one vote. Other than Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood, runners up have become much more successful. Casey has more talent in his little finger than all the others. And if Lauren wins, i'll never watch American Idol again. She's a cry baby and the judges are afraid to give her any constructive criticism because she gets that look in her face screaming "don't tell me anything negative or I'll start crying." I'll root for James now. Next to Casey, he has the most all-around talent.

Avatar

Casey has the talent. But it is his looks - too Jewish, almost like a rabbi.

Avatar

I don't feel American got it right tonight. My favorite is still in but I feel Casey was a lot better than some that got to stay. But he will go on and we will see a lot more of him.

Avatar

Thank god- finally! I dont know why the judges saved him anyways




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register