American Idol Results: Who Was Voted Off?

by at . Comments

After last week's shocking elimination of Pia Toscano on American Idol, we learned to be prepared for everything. No one is safe going into the results show.

Would someone we expected to stick around all season be ousted again tonight? Or would America cast its ballots more predictably this time? We had no clue.

We did accurately predict that three among these four - Jacob Lusk, Paul McDonald, Stefano Langone and Haley Reinhart - would comprise the final three.

Paul, Stefano and Haley earned the fewest votes after Wednesday night.

Follow the jump to see which of the three left American Idol tonight ...

Paul McDonald is on his way back to Nashville.

For the first time in six weeks, a guy was sent packing. Paul's gravelly voice and Southern charm carried him far, but couldn't get him over the hump tonight.

Paul McDonald on American Idol

"It's OK, man, it's OK. It's been fun, a good time," Paul told Ryan, before J. Lo offered a request for one more performance of Rod Stewart's "Maggie May."

What do you think? Did America blow it yet again this week, or was Paul McDonald actually deserving of the heave-ho from Idol? Sound off below ...

 

Tags:
Avatar

Yea it was his time to go. I called him the whisperer. He was a cross between Sting and Rod Stewart , but reminded me of a episode of Seinfeld where this gal spoke so low all you saw was her lips move and they kept going, "What did she say" Scott has this pretty much wrapped up. Great show this year. Great contestants and great judges. Injoyable at last.

Avatar

AND YES SCOTTY, ALL READY A NEW COUNTRY SINGING STAR... I'LL BUY ALL OF HIS CD'S... LOVE YOU,SCOTTY

Avatar

THEY ALL ARE VERY GOOD.... SAD TO SEE ANY GO HOME... VERY GOOD LUCK TO YOU ALL....

Avatar

American idol ch0ose d right one to v0te out its paul i really dnt like paul! American idol is weird i juz kept watching bcuz of james and they all idi0t bcuz pia the send h0me huhuhu..

Avatar

@ disgusted: Amen to your post. i have nothing else to say.

Avatar

@ Disgusted I couldn't agree more!!!

Avatar

From New Zealand, Jacob needs to go!!!!!!!

Avatar

i agree that Casey should have gone home when he was voted off but honestly that's really only because i'm not a big fan of facial hair and he really did suck that week. but he sort of halfway redeemed himself the week after and now he's kind of going downhill again................

Avatar

Swanky - Spare me your analysis, Dr. Phil. While you're handing out the condescending and uninvited therapy, you might want to take a look at your apparent need to presume to lecture a total stranger on what they "need to do." Life is so much bigger than allowing oneself to induldge in such self-important behavior. Just a thought.

Avatar

American idol is fuck up once again like ever year. I just don't understand why that they made such a big deal about pia when she left. Now they are not making a big deal about paul mcdonald left. What the fuck is going on is this world seriously come on? I like paul i though he was so dam talented his voice was differnet also you don't hear that kind of voice on the radio. My mom & i are really upset that paul was boot it off this week on american idol. If paul makes a cd i will like to get it because, he sang so dam good. Hopfuly next week scotty leaves. Because seriously he sucks. No a fance we don't need another willie nelson come on he needs to get the heck out of this singing computition. It makes me sick that he is still there. Come on seriously he needs to go packup his things & leave american idol to go back home. If he is safe again & somebody else leaves that is so talented then ones again american go it all fuckup. This is the reason why i don't like singing computition?

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]
× Close Ad