I love the arrangement of the music!His voice was just okay. I wish he would just sing instead of trying to over sing,then it would have been really good! However,he does commit to all of his performances and for that i can't be mad!:)
He has a voice, but guys, he doesn't have the ear. At the tonight results show he did it for the 3rd time, he was completely off the melody. This is inexcusable, it is actually painful to watch and listen to him now that he is consistently off. It's not even "pitchy", he just starts singing in a completely different key, then he finds his way back, but hello, this must have surfaced before and they should have never let him through to the top 24.
HE'S ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE!!!! What are those judges hearing? I don't get it at all. Luther Vandross, Marvin Gaye, those guys always sang with control and finesse and all Jacob does is SCREECH. He's rarely ever even on key.
I'm totally confused on how he's still in this competition. They said early on that it's a SINGING competition and they're looking for the best voice; not the worst voice with the most enthusiasm. What is going on this year????
Thanks for listening.
Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.
Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]
Comments (9 Total)
I love the arrangement of the music!His voice was just okay. I wish he would just sing instead of trying to over sing,then it would have been really good! However,he does commit to all of his performances and for that i can't be mad!:)
He has a voice, but guys, he doesn't have the ear. At the tonight results show he did it for the 3rd time, he was completely off the melody. This is inexcusable, it is actually painful to watch and listen to him now that he is consistently off. It's not even "pitchy", he just starts singing in a completely different key, then he finds his way back, but hello, this must have surfaced before and they should have never let him through to the top 24.
HE'S ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE!!!! What are those judges hearing? I don't get it at all. Luther Vandross, Marvin Gaye, those guys always sang with control and finesse and all Jacob does is SCREECH. He's rarely ever even on key. I'm totally confused on how he's still in this competition. They said early on that it's a SINGING competition and they're looking for the best voice; not the worst voice with the most enthusiasm. What is going on this year???? Thanks for listening.
I do didn't think he sang...'screeching' was more like it in several places. He looked very handsome.