Yesterday we played a video of Amber Portwood's baby daddy, Gary Shirley, laughing at and antagonizing the volatile, troubled Teen Mom star.
Often seen as the victim of her attacks, this cast Gary in a different light. Now, the audio below poses additional questions about Gary's role.
On December 15, Shirley desperately tried to get his other chick, a frequent target of Amber's threats, to cover up yet another beatdown.
Gary admits that Amber "f**king hit me" and can clearly be heard telling his girl how to stonewall reporters who got wind of the altercation.
In return for Ashley's silence, Gary says, "Maybe one day we can start a family." Isn't that the mentality that ... whatever, here's the tape: