18 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

Kara's foot was on the way out the door when she started posing nude. AI is still family orientated and showing skin for all the world to see does not add up to a wholesome image for the young American Idol contestants.Stay tuned!!

Avatar

A step up I say..but they could have kept Kara!! I like 4 judges. I love the J-Lo, and we'll just have to see how Tyler will do?? We may wish for Ellen.LOL!!

Avatar

OMG! NOT Jennifer and NOT Steven! Love them both BUT, not for Idol.
I THOUGHT Bret Michaels was a shoo in for this position! He is sensitive , honest and caring...
What really happened to Kara? SHe did a good job AND I did love Ellen on the show.. and did not think I would. SO just goes to show ya... one never knows.
This is one of my fave shows and I want it to go on and on so I will watch it no matter what...

RANDY.. SO HAPPY your still on .. you have always been my fave... hang in there Dooggg...!

Avatar

Kara has always been WAY TO FULL OF HERSELF! Bye-Bye Kara
Simon you love to hate...will sort of miss him
Ellen sweet Ellen my husband and I would laugh everytime she gave her opinion, she was total MISFIT for this how. Love to watch her show though.
I think JLo will do just fine
Steven Tyler, checks his bags before he sits down, NO ALCOHOL ALLOWED, makes silly people go STUPID things on National TV no less.
Randy, he is a great guy with a heart, happy he is staying.
Do not put Jessica Simpson on for pete sake, she is a flippin train wreck.

Avatar

Glad Kara is going..she was beautiful to look at but too full of herself. She drove me crazy. Ellen ....who cares..not me. Don't watch her show...don't like her. Harry Connick Jr. was the first person I thought of to replace Simon. He's to the point doesn't jack around and is damn easy on the eyes. Thank the Lord Randy is still there...Idol better test the personalities before they sign anyone. Still miss Paula..I know she's ditzy but she did know what she was talking about musically.

Avatar

I am glad Kara is gone. Couldn't stand her. She was always up in simon's face, she did everything but crawl in his lap. Good ridens. The show needs to go to.

Avatar

Time for idol to bid a fond farewell as well. Its been a nice run but its reaching and you feel it struggling.

Avatar

Oh DOG!! (pun intended) Why can't they get rid of Randy toooo!!!! WTH with Steven Tyler? Will he stay sober? I can't even imagine what he will be like. JLo I think will be boring. I actually think Jessica Simpson might have been funny, she's the queen of too much information. I REALLY wanted Chris Isaak, he's witty, hilarious and very smart. He would have brought a new edge (and prob new viewers) to the show.




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register