American Idol Sets Final 12, Sends Four Packing Comments (Page 2)
14 Comments
mela
March 12th, 2010 12:08 PM
tim? whhyyyyyyyy??!!! *groan*
okay, he's cute. whatEVER!
Just because his performance last week was his best doesn't mean he's even on par with anyone else! His stage fright annoys me and his voice is too nasally. He's NOT GOOD. Stop the denial, people.
Lilly was one of my top 4 girls. I'm sad but she has enough talent to make her own records.
My fav girls are Crystal (yeah ohio!) and Lacey. I like Siobhan but I'm not sure I really like her voice.
My fav guys are Casey and Andrew. They could sing the phone book and I would buy it!
Eli
March 12th, 2010 11:57 AM
I love to see more of Siobhan Magnus. She's definitely the DarkHorse of the group. She will amazed us next week for sure. I'm sad that Lily Scott didn't make it to the final 12. I think, she's more deserving to stay in Final 12 than Lacey or Paige or Katie. Also same fate happen to Alex Lambert, he's a good singer, more talented than Tim Urban or not that far away from Andrew Garcia. I think Alex is way more deserving to be in the final 12 rather than Tim and Andrew. I don't think that Andrew peak too early for the competition because of his acoustic version of Straight Up by Paula Abdul,i think it would be his last best performance and he had nothing more to offer. To sum it up, I'm not satisfied with the way the Final 12 selection goes on.
Lauryn
March 12th, 2010 8:19 AM
Tim was really good good this week. I don't see why you think Siobhan is so great?
Kelley
March 12th, 2010 7:37 AM
I'm in love with Tim Urban, I don't care what you say! :)
March 12th, 2010 12:08 PM
tim? whhyyyyyyyy??!!! *groan*
okay, he's cute. whatEVER!
Just because his performance last week was his best doesn't mean he's even on par with anyone else! His stage fright annoys me and his voice is too nasally. He's NOT GOOD. Stop the denial, people.
Lilly was one of my top 4 girls. I'm sad but she has enough talent to make her own records.
My fav girls are Crystal (yeah ohio!) and Lacey. I like Siobhan but I'm not sure I really like her voice.
My fav guys are Casey and Andrew. They could sing the phone book and I would buy it!
March 12th, 2010 11:57 AM
I love to see more of Siobhan Magnus. She's definitely the DarkHorse of the group. She will amazed us next week for sure. I'm sad that Lily Scott didn't make it to the final 12. I think, she's more deserving to stay in Final 12 than Lacey or Paige or Katie. Also same fate happen to Alex Lambert, he's a good singer, more talented than Tim Urban or not that far away from Andrew Garcia. I think Alex is way more deserving to be in the final 12 rather than Tim and Andrew. I don't think that Andrew peak too early for the competition because of his acoustic version of Straight Up by Paula Abdul,i think it would be his last best performance and he had nothing more to offer. To sum it up, I'm not satisfied with the way the Final 12 selection goes on.
March 12th, 2010 8:19 AM
Tim was really good good this week. I don't see why you think Siobhan is so great?
March 12th, 2010 7:37 AM
I'm in love with Tim Urban, I don't care what you say! :)