Aaron Kelly vs. Siobhan Magnus: Semifinalist Showdown!
The week after American Idol made its first round of cuts (sorry, Tyler, Janell, Ashley and Joe), we're continuing to ask readers which semifinalists they think will advance the farthest.
Past showdowns between singers, for example, have pitted Katie Stevens vs. Katelyn Epperly. Which of those young beauties has the most potential?
Now, for the first time in this feature, we're mixing up genders. Fox may wish to separate men and women like some sort of middle school dance, but THG is all about integration!
Last Tuesday, viewers voted Siobhan Magnus through after an impressive rendition of Chris Isaac's "Wicked Game." As an alternative to guitar players such as Didi Benami, Magnus may be a dark horse on the female side.
Meanwhile, Aaron Kelly also received good news from voters. His adorable mug will be on full display again this Wednesday. Choose between these contestants below...
Which semifinalist will advance farther on American Idol?
View Poll »
Related Posts
- Ethan Jones Does It For Dad on American Idol
- Lauren Gray on American Idol: The One and Only?
- Reis Kloeckener Makes Steven Tyler Cry
- Johnny Keyser on American Idol: FTW!
Rank: New User
March 19th, 2010 12:54 AM
how can you compare the weakest and strongest singers on the show like this?
obviously Siobhan is a potiential winner and Aaron, sweet and somewhat talented as he is, will just disappear and be forgotten.
It's a matter of talent, skill, personality, memorability, and experience. One has them all, the other has a little bit of the first two in that list.
March 1st, 2010 8:20 PM
I love Siobhan Magnus..I hope she wins...she's just so cute also!