240 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

Funny all you girls who are defending him for his "talent" *cough* Claudia *cough* The guy had to take off his shirt to get through. So much for talent. By the way his body isn't even that hot. It's average and boyish. No pecs or definition at all.

Avatar

The RULES of the show are that you are disqualified from competing if they find out that you have a criminal past which you did not initially tell them about. If he filled out his paperwork and told AI about all of his prior convictions, then it doesn't matter what he did in the past. If he lied about it and didn't write that he had ever been in trouble with the law, then that is a different story. Some of you bloggers and commenters should make sure you know what you're talking about before you start judging someone.

Avatar

He looks like a fine young man who has learned life the hard way. I believe he was in the hospital recovering from an accident years back and almost lost everything. He definately has talent and is very cute to look at.

Avatar

Casey is a great singer...people who judge others should take a look at themselves...Take time to see your own shallow life and do something about it!

Avatar

Seriously, what are the American Idol rules. SusanInFlorida who is so quick to judge. Do you even know? He paid the price for his crimes, and it was so long ago the statute of limitations has even expired. Wow, who did you know that didn't get through?

Avatar

He did these things years ago. How many people do stupid things in their past, grow up and live productive lives? We are so quick to judge. If he screws up today, well, that's a different scenario...

Avatar

Rules are rules. If this dude wants to violate the laws, then, Idol should ban him from their competition based on their own rules and regulations. Cut him a break just because he can sing? Hellllllllllllllllll noooooooooooooooooo! There are plenty of other singers without a criminal past who can and should replace him. Why reward his bad behavior? Send him to rehab and let's forget about his drunken past or his chances on AI.

Avatar

compared to Todrick Hall..his crime wasn't really that bad..and besided..if he can sing..let him sing..

Avatar

SERIOUSLY!!!!! Gives-a-shit just left the building. If the guy can croon then let the audience decide if he stays or goes!! What they need to do is get rid of Mrs. Beckham as a judge.....wasn't she the Spice Girl who was only good at showing off her legs?? Not much talent needed there. I think Simon should start thinking with his big-head and stop thinking about putting his 'pickle' in her knickers.

Avatar

Whatever! Who cares misdameanors over 7 years ago...Let's run your stats..




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register