Our celebrity fashion face-offs, in which you the reader vote on who wore an outfit best, usually center on identical or very similar getups stars wear to events.

Case in point: Alicia Keys and Carrie Underwood.

Their talent is unquestioned. Their fashion sense?

The disco-inspired dresses the beautiful singers recently were spotted in look pretty similar, but there can be only one winner when the gloves come off in our survey:

Who wore this better?