Earlier this week, we asked readers if they thought Adam Lambert should officially come out of the closet.
A majority of respondents so far have said no, Lambert doesn't owe it to anyone to announce that he's gay.
Based on her appearance on this morning's edition of The View, it sounds like Kara DioGuardi would reply similarly, but for a different reason: everyone already knows Adam is gay!
"I don't think that Adam was ever in [the closet]," the American Idol judge said. "I think he was always openly out."
That's not entirely true, of course. Lambert has never been ashamed to act in a certain matter (nor should he be), but he's gone out of his way to beat around the homosexual bush each time a reporter has broached the topic of his sexuality.
Asked by Barbara Walters whether the perception of being gay negatively affected Lambert's finish on the show, DioGuardi said:
"I hope not... because we should be judging on talent and viability in the music industry and they both [Lambert and winner Kris Allen] had that."
Do you agree? Do you think Lambert's sexual orientation cost him the American Idol crown?
Share
16 Comments
May 29th, 2009 11:22 AM
It's a good thing Adam didn't win! I believe he is a great singer, but our American Idol shouldn't be gay... that's just not right. We need an idol like Kris to be a good example to kids. Kelly Clarkson was and is another great role model. Ruben on the other hand, being obese? Not the best role model, don't you think?
May 29th, 2009 11:48 AM
Um, a person can be gay AND a good role model. Seriously homophobic there, aren't we? Adam seems like a good person and has been a good friend to Kris and is happy Kris won. It makes me sick that in this country we see gay people as "abnormal" or "evil". Completely blinded by politics and religion.
May 29th, 2009 12:55 PM
not homophobic, just practical! Would you want your kids to think "oh man this adam guy is cool, and he's gay, i want to be just like him," ? Don't think so! I never said Adam was a bad person, I actually really like him, I just don't think he would be the best choice to represent our country... and the majority of America apparently agrees, since Kris won. Religion and politics aside, I just don't think parents want their kids to think they should be gay just because he is, and there's no way of putting that info aside since it's already all over the news.
May 29th, 2009 2:03 PM
I personally don't think a white person from the south is a good role model either. I'd take a gay over a redneck bumpkin any day!
May 30th, 2009 4:44 AM
@EB... You're a loser... Go back to your farm!
Gay is not a look.... It's a choice. Kids should be tought that it is important to be yourself and not allow comments from 200 year old tossers such as youself stop them from reaching their true potential.
I am not gay, but I certainly will not judge anyone based on their choice on whom or what they love. This is exactly why Adam didn't win... viewers such as EB sitting on their wooden rocking chairs and seeing black finger polish or the metal studs or whatever and judging the look instead of the performance!
Go chew some tobacco on your porch, watch the sunset... Me and the rest of the sinners on this planet want to watch gays rocking on stage!
May 30th, 2009 12:01 PM
get a grip people. gay is just like straight only different.no choice, just being who you are. sheesh, get on with your lives and enjoy the ride.
May 30th, 2009 4:28 PM
First of all... I'm 18.
Second of all... my friends dress like Adam, and personally I love his style.
Third of all... there is absolutely nothing wrong with being country.
Kris is a good pure guy. I love both Adam and Kris. I'm sorry if I offended anyone. What I'm trying to get as is some kids think it's "trendy" to be gay and it's just a phase for them. But you're right, how is that Adams fault? I'll just leave it at "I'm glad Kris won... he's a great role model." :)
May 30th, 2009 9:59 PM
I don't think Kara had any right revealing her "opinions" about someone else, when, in fact, Adam says nothing but good things about her. It's Adam's business when and what he reveals about himself. Kara knows that he's not discussing his personal life with any of the media, so how dare her take it upon herself to discuss someone else's life. I was trying real hard to like her, but this turned me off.
May 30th, 2009 11:36 PM
I can't believe Kara beat Adam in revealing his true sexuality. Personally, I don't really care whether he is gay as long as he is a good person. I prefer Kris' music and singing, but I think Adam is also an amazing artist. Kris and Adam are BFF even though they are different. Let's leave it at that and just enjoy their music.
May 31st, 2009 11:11 PM
hmm.. even there is a GAY that is a good role model and that is Adam Lambert..he is a HUMAN too, not an abnormal guy! this is a singing competition not to find children idol.. and also there are many other famous singers that have some unique styles. just admit the differences! adam is unique! kid can have their own choice and adult can only advice them..it's their life!
and why is kara bothering adam's business? that is just wrong.. but whatever the real answer is i don't care. love adam forever..