Fashion Face-Off: Katie Cassidy vs. Melissa Rycroft

It's official. Melissa Rycroft is a major celebrity.

Sure, she starred on the highest-rated Bachelor finale in the show's history.

And, yes, we know she's currently a contestant on Dancing with the Stars.

But you aren't an A-lister until you've been featured on a THG Fashion Face-Off. Welcome to the club, Melissa.

Rycroft's opponent in this edition is Katie Cassidy, who will star in the upcoming remake of Melrose Place. Compare the looks below and then vote in our poll:

Who looks better in this dress?