American Idol Surprise: Judges Won't Save Alexis Grace

by at . Comments

More than 31 million votes were counted after Tuesday's country night and the results were announced on American Idol Wednesday. They were surprising.

Alexis Grace, considered by many to be an early favorite, instead landed at the bottom of the heap after her lackluster rendition of Dolly Parton's "Jolene."

Because of the newly instituted Judges' Save rule - and because the judges have always liked her so much - Alexis Grace was permitted to sing an encore.

But she didn't knock that out of the park either. Randy, Simon, Paula and Kara huddled together to discuss her fate, and decided it wasn't good enough.

Instead it was time for a farewell performance before packing her bags.

The other singer with Alexis in the bottom two, as predicted, was Michael Sarver, while 16-year-old Allison Iraheta, in a bit of a surprise, was third-to-last.

Those two and the other remaining eight constants have now achieved a significant goal, as they will comprise the Idols Live touring roster this summer.

Do you think Alexis Grace deserved to go? Who's your favorite to win now that the field is down to 10? Leave a comment below and let us know.

Then follow the jump for a video of our own Carrie Underwood and country legend Randy Travis "I Told You So" on the eighth season of American Idol ...


She deserved that save more than anyone i think it was the big fluke of the season But i think Adam And Danny are the top two


Alexis is talented...really they all are. The show is suppose to showcase the cream of the crop. The judges only have one save. I think they need to save the one that was voted out but could really have won. Like Daughtry...he could have won. Could Alexis have won? I am of the opinion not. Does it mean here future is shot? No way...Look at Bucky, Phil, Elliot...all have record deals.


what i don't get is why they basically said michael deserved to go, that they wouldnt have even asked him to sing again if he were in last, but then didnt bring alexis back. wtf!


I am so bored this the show this year. Nothing they could do or say would make me want to tune in. The singers aren't fantastic at all - they are good not great and an American Idol should be great. Granted a few that won over the years weren't great either and that's why they didn't become famous but it's a tired show - and I'm just plain tired of it all.


I love Alexis too... she was so cool and great and ... She was just unlucky. she was not meant for country. I'll miss her sooo much.
The judges only have one save. Maybe they dont want to use it yet.
Without Alexis, I think Danny stands a fair chance. He'll be the next American Idol.


I really like Alexis Grace...she is really great. I think they made a wrong decision in not giving her a second chance because i think that she can do better next time, they know her ability and she really has the talent...OMG...i want her back in the show...

Tags: ,

American Idol Quotes

Brooke White's tears come from the authentic, good soul that she is. Her heart was breaking because she was overwhelmed with the experience she had with the show and the gift that it brought.

Paula Abdul [after Brooke White was eliminated on season seven]

I read some of this online this morning and just for the record, the rumors — they’re not true. She’s part of our family and we love her.

Ryan Seacrest [on rumor of Paula Abdul being drunk on the show]