You are not signed in. Login or Register

New Song Showdown: Ali Lohan vs. David Archuleta vs. Miranda Cosgrove Comments (Page 3)

98 Comments

« Previous
Next »
1 2 3 4 5
  1. mccrack Says:

    David Archuleta is in a class by himself. It's really no contest. "Crush" is a #1 hit...David's georgeous voice and a very catchy and fun song! He is IN...CRED...I...BLE!!!

  2. Annie Says:

    Are you kidding me? Comparing David Archuleta with these two so-called singers? He's got the pure talent and wins hands down. Ali Lohan? Is this some kind of joke? Don't even know who the other girl is.

  3. Wendy Says:

    David should not even be compared to these two. He is in a league all his own. He is amazing.

  4. Linda Says:

    You must be kidding. Ali & Miranda should be band from ever making another record. Now, David Archuleta...WOW!!!!!
    What a voice and he relates to the tweens, cougars and we seasoned ladies.

  5. Jackie Says:

    David Archuleta is talented beyond his years (and beyond his peers) in singing, tone, pitch, renge, and interpretation. Sorry, no contest here.

  6. Caroll Says:

    Oh, please!!!! There is absolutely no comparison between these three songs! I couldn't even get through the two girls' songs! What horrid pop nightmares they are! These two girls are obviously banking on cuteness over talent. David's "Crush" has beautiful vocals, a catchy melody, and lyrics that are relatable. Granted, I am a big David Archuleta fan, but it's because of his undeniable talent as a vocalist, and his character as a human being! David totally rocks! "Crush" will be huge!!!

  7. andrea c Says:

    David A. all the way. "Crush" is by far the best. He is in a league of his own. He will be around for a long, long time.

  8. Hani Says:



    Crush... David A...he is the true star no doubt...

  9. juvecute Says:

    davids crush, crush them all..no contest
    crush wins 100%

  10. china Says:

    No comparison watsoever!!! David's 1st Hit Single is the BEST of the 3 song!!

    "CRUSH" is 1000x better just on pure VOCALS alone. Great lyrics, young or old, male or female, everyone can relate to this song. The melody is very comptemporary, radio friendly, appealing, catchy.

  11. Susan M. Says:

    Ali and Miranda are okay. David's Crush blows me away. Far better than the girls. It makes your whole body move. Love the beat.

  12. goboywonder Says:

    This is a joke right? It is unfair to embarrass the two young ladies like that. Well actually only Ms Cosgrove, Ms. Lohan's video was not available. CRUSH by far.

  13. Sylvia Says:

    David CRUSHed the competition!!!!!!

  14. zora Says:

    Crush is the no.1! The song is catchy and a perfect debut single for David! love love love Crush!

  15. barbs Says:

    Crush crushes, baby!

  16. Ed Says:

    Archuleta will be around decades after those 2 girls will.

    What kind of pointless comparison is this? It's like comparing a goldfish to a shark. David will eat them alive without even noticing.

    In otherwords, Archuleta's Crush, will crush.

  17. Amy Says:

    Loved CRUSH - Pop/R&B style, catchy, fresh, radio friendly - will appeal to a wider audience

    Other two were not in same class but definitely targeted for tweens, teens

  18. Kathy Says:

    I couldn't listen to Ali Lohan's song to judge.

    Miranda's song is... um... cute. I could imagine liking it if I was 8 or 9. A little too teen pop -- with a 'small' voice. But, hey, there's a huge market for that sound.

    David's song transcends any age market barriers. The subject matter is young, as he says himself in interviews, but his voice is so lush. I love the song because of the voice. Takes me back ... and makes me want to sing along.

  19. Becky Says:

    Crush, definitely. Archuleta is the best singer of all of them and his song is well-written and catchy.

  20. Jamie Says:

    I'm going to have to go with David Archuleta and Crush. It's much better than the other two. He has a beautiful voice.

  21. pam Says:

    The Crusher! David is the best! Make this go to number one! It is an amazing song from an incredible guy!!

  22. jessi Says:

    Ali and Miranda don't need to be compared to David Archuleta at this point in their careers. Please be kind to them and keep them in a different category. David transcends all ages and has such a pure voice - Crush is fabulous for his first single.

  23. Anne Says:

    CRUSH!!!! David Archuleta - a singer for ALL ages!!

  24. eliza Says:

    Crush is the best!

  25. Becca Says:

    Are u kidding me? Crush by Archuleta was the best (by a thousand miles)! Lohan and what's her name, ugg. You're joking right? Thanks for the laugh!

« Previous
Next »
1 2 3 4 5

Leave a Comment

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.

Name:

E-Mail:

Remember My Info

Your Comments
No need for HTML formatting, we insert line breaks. Allowed tags: <b> <i> <a>

Featured Posts

Adam Lambert American Music Awards Performance: Awesome or Inappropriate?
Adam Lambert American Music Awards Performance: Awesome or Inappropriate?
New Moon Review: The Hollywood Gossip Style
New Moon Review: The Hollywood Gossip Style
Levi Johnston Playgirl Pictures: Nude & Released!
Levi Johnston Playgirl Pictures: Nude & Released!

Featured Pics

Celebrities

Britney Spears
Britney Spears
Kim Kardashian
Kim Kardashian
Lauren Conrad
Lauren Conrad
Heidi Montag
Heidi Montag
Zac Efron
Zac Efron
Vanessa Hudgens
Vanessa Hudgens
Miley Cyrus
Miley Cyrus
Spencer Pratt
Spencer Pratt
Robert Pattinson
Robert Pattinson
Adam Lambert
Adam Lambert
Taylor Lautner
Taylor Lautner
Taylor Swift
Taylor Swift
Khloe Kardashian
Khloe Kardashian
Levi Johnston
Levi Johnston
Hailey Glassman
Hailey Glassman
Carrie Prejean
Carrie Prejean