Tale of the Tape: Carrie Underwood vs. Jessica Simpson
The Hollywood Gossip staff is proud to bring you Tale of the Tape, a feature in which we break down prospective matchups within the celebrity world. The following one that has been brewing for awhile - and is getting more heated by the day.
Carrie Underwood, our current Caption Contest subject, used to date Tony Romo, who is now dating Jessica Simpson. But he may still be pining for Carrie, and Jessica is jealous, and apparently talkin' smack about Carrie (see photo below)!
It's so on. Which of these women of Tony Romo will emerge victorious after a grueling, 10-round fight? Let's find out. Ding, ding!
Jessica Simpson takes a thinly-veiled shot at Carrie Underwood's vegetarianism.
1. ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE OTHER
Carrie Underwood: Not acknowledging the bitch
Jessica Simpson: Passive-aggressive t-shirts
Edge: Carrie
2. TALENT
Carrie Underwood: Loads
Jessica Simpson: N/A
Edge: Carrie
3. GRAMMY AWARDS
Carrie Underwood: 3
Jessica Simpson: N/A
Edge: Carrie
4. INSANE FATHERS
Carrie Underwood: N/A
Jessica Simpson: Joe Simpson
Edge: Carrie
5. SPORTS EXPERIENCE
Carrie Underwood: Solid charity softball player
Jessica Simpson: Bad luck Dallas Cowboys cheerleader
Edge: Carrie
6. POSSESSES FAKE ...
Carrie Underwood: Disdain for Simon Cowell
Jessica Simpson: Chin, Nose, Sincerity
Edge: Carrie
7. INTELLECTUAL ACHIEVEMENTS
Carrie Underwood: High school salutatorian; Graduated magna cum laude from Northeastern State University (Okla.), Class of 2006!
Jessica Simpson: Thought tuna was chicken
Edge: Carrie
8. MOST APPROPRIATE SONG TITLE
Carrie Underwood: "All-American Girl"
Jessica Simpson: "Push Your Tush"
Edge: Carrie
9. REALITY TV HIGHLIGHTS
Carrie Underwood: Winning American Idol
Jessica Simpson: Lots of dumb quotes on Newlyweds
Edge: Carrie
10. MOST LIKELY FUTURE
Carrie Underwood: Country Music Hall of Fame
Jessica Simpson: Soft-core porn
Edge: Carrie
THE VERDICT: The real country singer takes it - and for the first time in The Hollywood Gossip history, it's by a perfect, 10-0 score. By virtue of being blanked, Jessica must do a naked run. We're waiting, airhead.
Related Posts
- Jessica Simpson, Huge Boobs Attend Super Bowl
- Jessica Simpson Reveals Pregnancy Face
- Carrie Underwood Readies Fans for New Music [Video]
- Tale of the NFL Playoff Tape: Baltimore Ravens vs. New England Patriots



























November 17th, 2009 3:09 AM
This is really stupid. Carrie and Jessica are dumb for fighting and getting mad over nothing. But you're biast opinion is totally wrong. Because Jessica is better in her own ways way better than Carrie and vice versa. So all ya'll biast people out there can kiss ass because ya'll are all just so damn retarded for being one one side than the other.
August 21st, 2008 9:35 PM
I wish the music company would eliminate this douche bag hoe in the music industry. She should go back to school and whore around and find a job at like Quiktrip. She does a much better job at whoring around because she has it easy, all she has to do is lay there with her legs open. Im sure thats exactly what she did for QUEERBAIT Tony "Fago" Im sure he coated her throat with his sperm everyday. To bad is didnt make the bitch lose her voice.
July 13th, 2008 9:27 AM
carrie is way better than that jessica carrie is real while jessica is not
June 30th, 2008 12:04 AM
Jessica's being a catty b*tch! She better watch it, Tony looks happier in the pictures with Carrie.
June 26th, 2008 10:00 AM
CARRIE ROCKS!!! JESSICA IS A BITCH!!! GO CARRIE I'M WITH YA 1000%
June 26th, 2008 9:56 AM
I HATE JESSICA WITH A PASSION!!! SHE'S A A NO GOOD BITCH WHO'S SO OBSSSED WITH WANTING TO BE LIKE CARRIE BECAUSE SHE KNOWS CARRIE IS A BEAUTIFUL SUCCESSFUL YOUNG LADY WHO MAKES LOTS OF CASH JESSICA IS SO DAMN JELOUS THATS WHY SHE WORE THAT HIDIOUS SHIRT BECAUSE SHE WANTS CARRIE TO WALK UP AND SEE HER!! WELL I GOT NEWS FOR HER, SHE DOESN'T CARE AND SHE DOESN'T WANT TONY BACK BECAUSE HE WAS NOOOOOOO GOOD ANYWAY!!!! I WANT JESSICA TO BE DUMPED BY TONY BECAUSE WITH THAT OLD BOYISH LOOK I HONESTLY DON'T KNO HOW SHE COULD GET ANY MAN! NICK OBVIOULSY DIDN'T LIKE HER EATHIER SO HE MOVED ON!!! JESSICA, GO SCREW YOURSELF AND LEAVE CARRIE ALONE!!!!!!!
June 22nd, 2008 9:54 PM
Let's see... Carrie has had 2 albums under her belt and has sold over 20 million units worldwide. How many albums did it take for Jessica to reach that milestone? Has she reached it yet? Hmmm... Edge still goes to Carrie.
June 16th, 2008 11:29 PM
I don't know why Jessica has to be so jealous over a friend of Tony's. It shows how childess she is by asking him to give her up as a friend. She needs to have some confidence in herself. Tony could have had Carrie but he likes dating several women at one time. Carrie doesnt play that game. So now she got all famous and he wants her now. Carrie doesnt play that game. She's too smart. Knows what he's up to.
June 16th, 2008 8:24 PM
Ugh, I can't stand Carrie Underwood.
June 16th, 2008 6:16 PM
Jessica is a stupid bitch. I cannot wait for Tony to dump her again.
I seriously doubt Carrie wants his whiny ass back either.
Jessica can't hold a candle compared to Carrie, in talent, class, or looks.
Jessica looks like a shemale in the face, and Carrie is equisite.
Jessica blows chunks. She is such a twit. Can't stand that HO.