You are not signed in. Login or Register

Tale of the Tape: Carrie Underwood vs. Jessica Simpson

The Hollywood Gossip staff is proud to bring you Tale of the Tape, a feature in which we break down prospective matchups within the celebrity world. The following one that has been brewing for awhile - and is getting more heated by the day.

Carrie Underwood, our current Caption Contest subject, used to date Tony Romo, who is now dating Jessica Simpson. But he may still be pining for Carrie, and Jessica is jealous, and apparently talkin' smack about Carrie (see photo below)!

It's so on. Which of these women of Tony Romo will emerge victorious after a grueling, 10-round fight? Let's find out. Ding, ding!

Real Girls Eat MeatTony Romo, Carrie Underwood

Jessica Simpson takes a thinly-veiled shot at Carrie Underwood's vegetarianism.

1. ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE OTHER

Carrie Underwood: Not acknowledging the bitch
Jessica Simpson: Passive-aggressive t-shirts
Edge: Carrie

2. TALENT

Carrie Underwood: Loads
Jessica Simpson: N/A
Edge: Carrie

3. GRAMMY AWARDS

Carrie Underwood: 3
Jessica Simpson: N/A
Edge: Carrie

4. INSANE FATHERS

Carrie Underwood: N/A
Jessica Simpson: Joe Simpson
Edge: Carrie

5. SPORTS EXPERIENCE

Carrie Underwood: Solid charity softball player
Jessica Simpson: Bad luck Dallas Cowboys cheerleader
Edge: Carrie

6. POSSESSES FAKE ...

Carrie Underwood: Disdain for Simon Cowell
Jessica Simpson: Chin, Nose, Sincerity
Edge: Carrie

7. INTELLECTUAL ACHIEVEMENTS

Carrie Underwood: High school salutatorian; Graduated magna cum laude from Northeastern State University (Okla.), Class of 2006!
Jessica Simpson: Thought tuna was chicken
Edge: Carrie

8. MOST APPROPRIATE SONG TITLE

Carrie Underwood: "All-American Girl"
Jessica Simpson: "Push Your Tush"
Edge: Carrie

9. REALITY TV HIGHLIGHTS

Carrie Underwood: Winning American Idol
Jessica Simpson: Lots of dumb quotes on Newlyweds
Edge: Carrie

10. MOST LIKELY FUTURE

Carrie Underwood: Country Music Hall of Fame
Jessica Simpson: Soft-core porn
Edge: Carrie

THE VERDICT: The real country singer takes it - and for the first time in The Hollywood Gossip history, it's by a perfect, 10-0 score. By virtue of being blanked, Jessica must do a naked run. We're waiting, airhead.

Related Posts


17 Comments

Next »
1 2
  1. AARKIEAM FIELDS Says:

    It seem no matter how much money someone has or happy they may seem there is always someone trying to take their shine. Jessica Simpson and Carrie Underwood should give him up. IF he is p[laying both sides of the fence they shouldn't allow themselves to be fouled. There are Millions and LMilions of men in this World and those two females are so wanted by many who would treat them greatly. Ladies sloppy seconds and thirds are no good and HIV is stilling around.

  2. Stacey Says:

    Funny, I'd take Jessica over that bitch anyday.

  3. Keep telling yourself that crap... Says:

    1. ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE OTHER

    Carrie Underwood: Not acknowledging the bitch
    Jessica Simpson: Passive-aggressive t-shirts
    Edge: Carrie
    ____

    Have you HEARD Carrie Underwood's interviews? She's comments on them all the time and is cleary bitter.

  4. Lauryn Says:

    Hollywood Gossip, I must say...I'm totally with you on this one! Carrie wins 10-0...on class alone!

  5. mikayla Says:

    i think the media just wants to juice up the story, dont get me wrong i do believe that jessica is jealous it sounds like her at least if were going by how she was on newlyweds she was so whiny complaining and was jealous with nick of chicks...so that part doesn't surprise me jessica is so insecure and the fact that she is wearing a shirt that is mocking carrie since she is veggetarian thinking this will hurt carrie bitch please the girl has 3 grammy's and is doing awesome with her career it clear that jessica is a jealous bitch a bitch and so dam catty she wants carrie's life...she is an idiot...carrie probably doesn't want romo back she's moved on and romo is still hung up on her because he knows he let go of a good thing a beatifull successfull intelligent sweet woman!! everything jessica lacks of course duhh he wants carrie back!! grow up jessica grow up you little pathetic catty wannabe carrie stupid bitch!! i wanna be a country singer kjust like carrie yeah good luck with that whore!!

  6. Dee Says:

    This is ridiculous. Who cares?

  7. Barbara Says:

    You go Carrie!

  8. judy Says:

    Jessica is a stupid bitch. I cannot wait for Tony to dump her again.
    I seriously doubt Carrie wants his whiny ass back either.
    Jessica can't hold a candle compared to Carrie, in talent, class, or looks.
    Jessica looks like a shemale in the face, and Carrie is equisite.
    Jessica blows chunks. She is such a twit. Can't stand that HO.

  9. Yeehaw Says:

    Ugh, I can't stand Carrie Underwood.

  10. Texas Says:

    I don't know why Jessica has to be so jealous over a friend of Tony's. It shows how childess she is by asking him to give her up as a friend. She needs to have some confidence in herself. Tony could have had Carrie but he likes dating several women at one time. Carrie doesnt play that game. So now she got all famous and he wants her now. Carrie doesnt play that game. She's too smart. Knows what he's up to.

Next »
1 2

Leave a Comment

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.

Name:

E-Mail:

Remember My Info

Your Comments
No need for HTML formatting, we insert line breaks. Allowed tags: <b> <i> <a>

Follow Us!

The Hollywood Gossip Twitter The Hollywood Gossip Facebook THG Newsetter THG RSS

Featured Posts

Brooklyn Decker Removes Top, Covers 2010 Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition
Brooklyn Decker Removes Top, Covers 2010 Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition
The Bachelor Recap: Ali Fedotowsky Drops a Bomb
The Bachelor Recap: Ali Fedotowsky Drops a Bomb
NOOOO! John Mayer Allegedly Brags About Taylor Swift Hook-Up
NOOOO! John Mayer Allegedly Brags About Taylor Swift Hook-Up

Featured Pics

Celebrities

Britney Spears
Britney Spears
Kim Kardashian
Kim Kardashian
Heidi Montag
Heidi Montag
Zac Efron
Zac Efron
Vanessa Hudgens
Vanessa Hudgens
Miley Cyrus
Miley Cyrus
Spencer Pratt
Spencer Pratt
Robert Pattinson
Robert Pattinson
Adam Lambert
Adam Lambert
Taylor Lautner
Taylor Lautner
Taylor Swift
Taylor Swift
Khloe Kardashian
Khloe Kardashian
Kate Gosselin
Kate Gosselin
Tila Tequila
Tila Tequila
Tiger Woods
Tiger Woods
Levi Johnston
Levi Johnston