We suppose that's actually a good thing - not to mention a pretty rare feat, and a huge compliment for a bona fide, All-American star.
But we think we could allow the American Idol and Grammy-winning singer to let her success and good looks go to her head a little bit.
Witness the celebrity quote below ...
"I don't consider myself sexy ... I'm kind of a nervous person in general," says Underwood, 25, in the July issue of Cosmopolitan.
"I'm socially awkward. I'm not tall and sensuous. I usually wear sweats everywhere I go. Oh, and I burp a lot."
THG NOTE: Will you marry us right now, Carrie?
Despite being the consensus #1 on The Hollywood Gossip Desirability Scale, Carrie Underwood has had some messy breakups in the past.
Idiots like Chace Crawford and Tony Romo (who, according to some celebrity gossip sources, is regretting this error) let her get away.
While she doesn't name names, she tells Cosmopolitan that, "Cheating is a deal breaker â€" If you cheat, you're gone." Amen, girl.
Just the same, the beautiful, blonde Oklahoma native doesn't believe in plotting revenge against her ex-boyfriends.
"Getting revenge on a guy is just not worth it to me," she says. "The best revenge I can think of is becoming famous."