Another American Idol Shocker: Carly Smithson Eliminated! Comments (Page 2)
42 Comments
jane jacques
May 1st, 2008 10:21 AM
carly shuld never been sent home. you have brook who in my opinion is awful,little david he sings the same way all the time and jason i won't go there. carly should have at least been in the top two. i'm a david cook fan but it should have been between carly and david. i don't even watch anymore it's true all the young are voting on who's cute.judges should have the last say.
james
April 30th, 2008 7:35 PM
its truly upsetting. she was the best vocalist of the entire show, as well as my favorite. any sane person could tell you she didnt deserve to sent home, and i am truly disapointed in america...
furthermore, not only did brooke and jason deliver horrible performances, but they did this week as well. but america will vote the syesha...
Cheri
April 29th, 2008 10:53 AM
No she never should have been voted off on her sining ability, because that was there. Amercia has American Idol as a popularity contest. Brooke should have gone and Jason, but no.....they are popular. Come on Carly has tattoos and Not all of America likes that. And her husband is full of them. I really hate it when America stero types. I am sad that she is gone from the show, but she will do well!!!!
Dianne
April 24th, 2008 11:31 PM
What a disgrace - America you should be ashamed of yourselves - It was bad enough that Michael Johns got axed but now Smithson - This show is about TALENT not boyish good looks or who feels sorry for who - I am watching this from New Zealand - In my opinion the final three should have been Johns - Smithson and Cook who will be next COOK come on America forget the sympathy votes or 'OH he's so cute" vote its time for 'He's BRILLIANT' Vote. At this rate we will end up switching of American Idol as its turning into a joke.
Cheryl Outhier
April 24th, 2008 5:03 PM
No way, that girl is the best of the women. It would have been between her and David Cook...........
Elizabeth
April 24th, 2008 1:10 PM
Thank you for a place to finally voice my frustation!!! I am so sick of Brooke's quivering lower lip or the upper lip brought to disappearing the only thing missing is for her to curl her hair and suck her thumb! I am afraid I agree with Paula about the stopping and starting over!! Do you remember when David stumbled on Beatles week? Well he never did it again, which just proves a good work ethic. If you recall Brooke sat at the piano and started to sing then stopped and started over. That is not one stumble it is TWO! How many chances does she get???? Carly didn't deserve to go home last night and Brooke knew that! I sometimes wonder if when someone is eliminated that shouldn't be if the person who should have been going home ever feels like they have enough self-repect to stand up and say, "I am sorry but Carly should not be going home I should and so for that reason I will take her place" now there would be someone who had self respect and was professional enough to be ca
alexa
April 24th, 2008 12:10 PM
I AGREE. Jason or Brooke should've gone. I was a BIG TIME Michael Johns supporter, and when he got eliminated, it was totally unfair. My 2nd favorite was Carly... and she was 100% totally unfairly eliminated! I am now officially anti-American Idol. What are American Idol watchers thinking?!
Michael Guinn
April 24th, 2008 10:34 AM
Carly's dismissal from Idol last evening was a joke. It's taken a while for her to grow on me, but she is actually quite good and deserved to be in the top 3-4 easily.
Jason and Brooke should have been in the bottom two. I like Brooke but she should have not been saved. Sad but true.
arc angel
April 24th, 2008 8:08 AM
ABSOLUTELY NOT! Why Brook White didn't go home, I'm clueless.. and let's face it, so was she. White looked absolutely suprised when they called her safe. And even when she wasn't knocked off, between Jason and Carly, Jason should definitely have been in the bottom two! (Don't get me wrong, he's been a fav of mine from the get go) but last Tuesday night just wasn't his thing. All I can say is it has definitely been a surprising American Idol Season. Good Luck Carly!
Patti
April 24th, 2008 7:06 AM
Carly was ripped off. The voting system does not reflect the opinion of the majority of viewers/voters. People have figured out how to rig the voting for their "popular favorite". No way should Carly leave while Jason and Brooke still remain. And Syesha should never have been in the bottom two this week. She showed tremendous talent & versatility on Tuesday night. Go Syesha!
bill
April 24th, 2008 6:54 AM
i think it's a populatiy contest not singing
ilovecarlysmithson
April 24th, 2008 6:19 AM
no she did not deserve to be eliminated and i dont understand how people could vote for jason freak or brooke the baby? they both did awful and they BOTH desere to go home!!!!!! i voted 4 carly at least 40 times but oviously other people did not!!! thank u all that aare her fans and thanks to everyone who did vote for carly and not for jason or brooke. carly will be a superstar and i know it!!!!!!!!!
Tim Fritz
April 24th, 2008 5:44 AM
Unbelievable! Obviously the result of an audience made up of passive listeners and not active listeners. As a experienced and retired bass player for a symphony orchestra, jazz and rock bands I recognize talent. This girl lit up the stage every week. She sang with incredible enthusiam, emotion, and had a great attitude. Carly should have been in at least the top four. Two of the remaining contestants should have already gone home and they know it as well! Carly is one step away from becoming a superstar!
Renato
April 24th, 2008 4:16 AM
Of Course, Americans would be very disappointed to see a foreigner who sings better than any other of their beloved American contestants. She's by far the best singer that ever aplied for American Idol.
gail banfield
April 24th, 2008 3:05 AM
carly should have wound up in the final three. if simon caldwell wasn't so hot i would not finish the season.
gail banfield
April 24th, 2008 3:01 AM
i and i believe almost your whole viewing audience would agree carly should be in the final 3 winners, how the three would fair at the end would be anyones guess.
gail banfield
April 24th, 2008 3:01 AM
i and i believe almost your whole viewing audience would agree carly should be in the final 3 winners, how the three would fair at the end would be anyones guess.
gail banfield
April 24th, 2008 3:01 AM
i and i believe almost your whole viewing audience would agree carly should be in the final 3 winners, how the three would fair at the end would be anyones guess.
Grita
April 24th, 2008 2:25 AM
Oh my god. When I read this news. Suddenly, I was crying because her performance last night was absolutely great. She's my favourite. Because come on, this is a SINGING COMPETITION. ( Most of the people don't think so). But I'm sure Simon was surprised too. After all she was one of his favourites.
samantha
April 24th, 2008 1:56 AM
I agree that Carly had a better performance. Heck, she's the best singer, technically, but, I don't agree that she was the most charismatic star of the season. I think there's something very annoying about her hyper mannerisms, and while she was blessed with a gorgeous instrument, her own zeal and personality undermines her performances. While she sung well last night, she still missed the mark for me because I'm tired of her sass and ego. She acts like she's the greatest star, and truthfully, star quality is a recipe of ingredients. On every cruise ship and local bars throughout the world one can find exceptionally talented singers, but, stars are something which combine talent, and other factors. It was time for Carly to go away.
gelene
April 24th, 2008 1:33 AM
definitely no! what a stupid decision America did tonight!
Dorothy
April 24th, 2008 12:31 AM
Carly should have stayed! She gave a great performance and is a super singer. If there was anyone who needed to leave, it was Jason. His performance was terrible and he was off key quite a bit. I honestly don't know why he is still in the top 5. He is not that good of a singer and that hair has got to go!
cheryl
April 24th, 2008 12:16 AM
Carly has had some tough critiques and survived to sing another song. Tonight's elimination was not only unexpected but completely undeserved. I like Brooke but think that either she or Jason should have been voted off!
Glich
April 24th, 2008 12:13 AM
No, Smithson didn't deserve to leave!
boomdizzle
April 23rd, 2008 11:56 PM
hell no that fuc$%& bi%&& brooke "G-rated nanny" had to go. you dont forget lyrics this late in the competition. (david a also did that, but much earlier around the top 11) please hollywoodgossip.com. petition for her eliminination please!!!!! that undeserving h0&
May 1st, 2008 10:21 AM
carly shuld never been sent home. you have brook who in my opinion is awful,little david he sings the same way all the time and jason i won't go there. carly should have at least been in the top two. i'm a david cook fan but it should have been between carly and david. i don't even watch anymore it's true all the young are voting on who's cute.judges should have the last say.
April 30th, 2008 7:35 PM
its truly upsetting. she was the best vocalist of the entire show, as well as my favorite. any sane person could tell you she didnt deserve to sent home, and i am truly disapointed in america...
furthermore, not only did brooke and jason deliver horrible performances, but they did this week as well. but america will vote the syesha...
April 29th, 2008 10:53 AM
No she never should have been voted off on her sining ability, because that was there. Amercia has American Idol as a popularity contest. Brooke should have gone and Jason, but no.....they are popular. Come on Carly has tattoos and Not all of America likes that. And her husband is full of them. I really hate it when America stero types. I am sad that she is gone from the show, but she will do well!!!!
April 24th, 2008 11:31 PM
What a disgrace - America you should be ashamed of yourselves - It was bad enough that Michael Johns got axed but now Smithson - This show is about TALENT not boyish good looks or who feels sorry for who - I am watching this from New Zealand - In my opinion the final three should have been Johns - Smithson and Cook who will be next COOK come on America forget the sympathy votes or 'OH he's so cute" vote its time for 'He's BRILLIANT' Vote. At this rate we will end up switching of American Idol as its turning into a joke.
April 24th, 2008 5:03 PM
No way, that girl is the best of the women. It would have been between her and David Cook...........
April 24th, 2008 1:10 PM
Thank you for a place to finally voice my frustation!!! I am so sick of Brooke's quivering lower lip or the upper lip brought to disappearing the only thing missing is for her to curl her hair and suck her thumb! I am afraid I agree with Paula about the stopping and starting over!! Do you remember when David stumbled on Beatles week? Well he never did it again, which just proves a good work ethic. If you recall Brooke sat at the piano and started to sing then stopped and started over. That is not one stumble it is TWO! How many chances does she get???? Carly didn't deserve to go home last night and Brooke knew that! I sometimes wonder if when someone is eliminated that shouldn't be if the person who should have been going home ever feels like they have enough self-repect to stand up and say, "I am sorry but Carly should not be going home I should and so for that reason I will take her place" now there would be someone who had self respect and was professional enough to be ca
April 24th, 2008 12:10 PM
I AGREE. Jason or Brooke should've gone. I was a BIG TIME Michael Johns supporter, and when he got eliminated, it was totally unfair. My 2nd favorite was Carly... and she was 100% totally unfairly eliminated! I am now officially anti-American Idol. What are American Idol watchers thinking?!
April 24th, 2008 10:34 AM
Carly's dismissal from Idol last evening was a joke. It's taken a while for her to grow on me, but she is actually quite good and deserved to be in the top 3-4 easily.
Jason and Brooke should have been in the bottom two. I like Brooke but she should have not been saved. Sad but true.
April 24th, 2008 8:08 AM
ABSOLUTELY NOT! Why Brook White didn't go home, I'm clueless.. and let's face it, so was she. White looked absolutely suprised when they called her safe. And even when she wasn't knocked off, between Jason and Carly, Jason should definitely have been in the bottom two! (Don't get me wrong, he's been a fav of mine from the get go) but last Tuesday night just wasn't his thing. All I can say is it has definitely been a surprising American Idol Season. Good Luck Carly!
April 24th, 2008 7:06 AM
Carly was ripped off. The voting system does not reflect the opinion of the majority of viewers/voters. People have figured out how to rig the voting for their "popular favorite". No way should Carly leave while Jason and Brooke still remain. And Syesha should never have been in the bottom two this week. She showed tremendous talent & versatility on Tuesday night. Go Syesha!
April 24th, 2008 6:54 AM
i think it's a populatiy contest not singing
April 24th, 2008 6:19 AM
no she did not deserve to be eliminated and i dont understand how people could vote for jason freak or brooke the baby? they both did awful and they BOTH desere to go home!!!!!! i voted 4 carly at least 40 times but oviously other people did not!!! thank u all that aare her fans and thanks to everyone who did vote for carly and not for jason or brooke. carly will be a superstar and i know it!!!!!!!!!
April 24th, 2008 5:44 AM
Unbelievable! Obviously the result of an audience made up of passive listeners and not active listeners. As a experienced and retired bass player for a symphony orchestra, jazz and rock bands I recognize talent. This girl lit up the stage every week. She sang with incredible enthusiam, emotion, and had a great attitude. Carly should have been in at least the top four. Two of the remaining contestants should have already gone home and they know it as well! Carly is one step away from becoming a superstar!
April 24th, 2008 4:16 AM
Of Course, Americans would be very disappointed to see a foreigner who sings better than any other of their beloved American contestants. She's by far the best singer that ever aplied for American Idol.
April 24th, 2008 3:05 AM
carly should have wound up in the final three. if simon caldwell wasn't so hot i would not finish the season.
April 24th, 2008 3:01 AM
i and i believe almost your whole viewing audience would agree carly should be in the final 3 winners, how the three would fair at the end would be anyones guess.
April 24th, 2008 3:01 AM
i and i believe almost your whole viewing audience would agree carly should be in the final 3 winners, how the three would fair at the end would be anyones guess.
April 24th, 2008 3:01 AM
i and i believe almost your whole viewing audience would agree carly should be in the final 3 winners, how the three would fair at the end would be anyones guess.
April 24th, 2008 2:25 AM
Oh my god. When I read this news. Suddenly, I was crying because her performance last night was absolutely great. She's my favourite. Because come on, this is a SINGING COMPETITION. ( Most of the people don't think so). But I'm sure Simon was surprised too. After all she was one of his favourites.
April 24th, 2008 1:56 AM
I agree that Carly had a better performance. Heck, she's the best singer, technically, but, I don't agree that she was the most charismatic star of the season. I think there's something very annoying about her hyper mannerisms, and while she was blessed with a gorgeous instrument, her own zeal and personality undermines her performances. While she sung well last night, she still missed the mark for me because I'm tired of her sass and ego. She acts like she's the greatest star, and truthfully, star quality is a recipe of ingredients. On every cruise ship and local bars throughout the world one can find exceptionally talented singers, but, stars are something which combine talent, and other factors. It was time for Carly to go away.
April 24th, 2008 1:33 AM
definitely no! what a stupid decision America did tonight!
April 24th, 2008 12:31 AM
Carly should have stayed! She gave a great performance and is a super singer. If there was anyone who needed to leave, it was Jason. His performance was terrible and he was off key quite a bit. I honestly don't know why he is still in the top 5. He is not that good of a singer and that hair has got to go!
April 24th, 2008 12:16 AM
Carly has had some tough critiques and survived to sing another song. Tonight's elimination was not only unexpected but completely undeserved. I like Brooke but think that either she or Jason should have been voted off!
April 24th, 2008 12:13 AM
No, Smithson didn't deserve to leave!
April 23rd, 2008 11:56 PM
hell no that fuc$%& bi%&& brooke "G-rated nanny" had to go. you dont forget lyrics this late in the competition. (david a also did that, but much earlier around the top 11) please hollywoodgossip.com. petition for her eliminination please!!!!! that undeserving h0&