It was an evening where one American Idol finalist forgot the lyrics (sorry, Brooke White), while another almost made us forget that David Cook and David Archuleta were the front-runners (way to go, Syesha Mercado).
Relive Andrew Lloyd Webber night right now with the following photos of the contestants belting out Broadway hits.
Click on each thumbnail for a larger picture and let us know: Which was your favorite performance?





























April 23rd, 2008 7:35 AM
I don't know, I found them all a little bit boring last night. I think Jason and Brooke are in trouble.
The show isn't the same for me without Michael Johns!