I agree with Jay for the most part. He made a bad choice choosing the song that he chose, but there have been much worse mistakes... KRISTY LEE COOK. OH MY GOD. that country rendition of 8 Days a Week... she butchered the song. and the song she did last week, I had to change the channel for a second, I couldn't even listen to it. I'm not sure if it was a CONSPIRACY... maybe it was, people are so close minded, and if American Idol stooped so low, it really is a shame how close minded we have become. It also could have just been the homophobes and the bible thumpers (I'm sorry but it's true) voting against him because of his life on the side. He definitely deserves to be there, his voice is just amazing (NOT TO MENTION LOOKS...) I could go on forever, but all in all I think he should still be there.
Lesley Mccormick Says:
March 20th, 2008 8:21 AM
Elizabeth hit it right on!! This was definately a conspiracy. The judges suddenly went cold on David who they had loved up until then. David was not voted out because he had no talent - the opposite is true - he had one of the best vocals in the competition. American Idol will never be the same for me. I miss David!!
Rose Casey Says:
May 16th, 2008 11:12 PM
I think David Hernandez should have stayed on Idol. He has way better vocals than Jason Castro, Christy Lee Cook, Ramiel, etc. I believe Idol chose to boot him over the stories regarding his past and make it easy on themselves by saying he had the lowest votes--no controversy that way. Did you notice how sad he looked at the beginning of the show and through out it?
Irregardless of his past, he has great talent, and I wish only the best for his future. I would love to see him and hear him again.
Give me a break--we had Rock Hudson, who was gay, Richard Chamberlain, and many others--some out of the closet and some not. I can understand booting those twins from a previous show who were under indictment for fraud, but a real talent just cause he stripped in a gay bar? Unreal!!
March 19th, 2008 5:19 PM
I agree with Jay for the most part. He made a bad choice choosing the song that he chose, but there have been much worse mistakes... KRISTY LEE COOK. OH MY GOD. that country rendition of 8 Days a Week... she butchered the song. and the song she did last week, I had to change the channel for a second, I couldn't even listen to it. I'm not sure if it was a CONSPIRACY... maybe it was, people are so close minded, and if American Idol stooped so low, it really is a shame how close minded we have become. It also could have just been the homophobes and the bible thumpers (I'm sorry but it's true) voting against him because of his life on the side. He definitely deserves to be there, his voice is just amazing (NOT TO MENTION LOOKS...) I could go on forever, but all in all I think he should still be there.
March 20th, 2008 8:21 AM
Elizabeth hit it right on!! This was definately a conspiracy. The judges suddenly went cold on David who they had loved up until then. David was not voted out because he had no talent - the opposite is true - he had one of the best vocals in the competition. American Idol will never be the same for me. I miss David!!
May 16th, 2008 11:12 PM
I think David Hernandez should have stayed on Idol. He has way better vocals than Jason Castro, Christy Lee Cook, Ramiel, etc. I believe Idol chose to boot him over the stories regarding his past and make it easy on themselves by saying he had the lowest votes--no controversy that way. Did you notice how sad he looked at the beginning of the show and through out it?
Irregardless of his past, he has great talent, and I wish only the best for his future. I would love to see him and hear him again.
Give me a break--we had Rock Hudson, who was gay, Richard Chamberlain, and many others--some out of the closet and some not. I can understand booting those twins from a previous show who were under indictment for fraud, but a real talent just cause he stripped in a gay bar? Unreal!!