Fashion Face-Off: Ashley Tisdale vs. Holly Madison

by at . Comments

Thanks to her new nose, it's difficult to even recognize Ashley Tisdale.

But we're pretty sure that is the High School Musical star below, shimmering in a dress from this year's American Music Awards.

Looking similar to the young singer/actress? One of Hugh Hefner's Girls Next Door, as Holly Madison shows off her assets in a silver sequined dress at a recent holiday party in Los Angeles.

Ashley Tisdale, Holly Madison

Once you decide if the clothed Playboy Bunny looks better than Tisdale, let us know if Holly Madison nude is more attractive than Carmella DeCesare nude.

Tags: , ,
Like Us On Facebook

More From The Hollywood Gossip


Robyn Lawley Still Considered Plus-Size, Internet Throws Collective Fit Over Bikini Photo

Robyn Lawley, the 25-year-old brunette beauty and "plus-size" model, is again stirring debate over what it means to be considered plus-sized.

Britney Spears Lingerie Photo Teases New Intimate Apparel Line, Men Everywhere

Britney Spears in lingerie is a beautiful thing. Soon we hope there will be many more advertisements like this one.

Lauren Conrad: Allure Called Me "Basic B!tch" With Sausage Curls!

Lauren Conrad is anything but basic - to us - but Allure apparently views her as somewhat less exceptional than THG's editorial department.

Kendall Jenner: Topless For LOVE Magazine!

Kendall Jenner is becoming the model of the moment, surpassing the buzz of even half-sister Kim. See her latest spread here.


guys are u freaking kidding me holly is a billion times prettier than Ashley. it fits holly way better Ashley has no boobs to fill out the dress she just straight out looks like crap. Holly all the way 100% ashley ur a terrible actor and ur ugly as hell. go holly!


I can't believe what I am reading here! I think everyone who comented must be like 16 year old girls or something because when I look at these photos there is just no comparison, ashley looks ugly all the way! Holly is pretty and the dress looks better on her hands down. hooray for boobs


and i love her hairstyle!!^^


of course ashley, i'm huge fan of her, go go go ashley but i hate her BFF-Vanessa, she sucks!


Holly is ALOT prettier than Ashley. Plus, I've been told I look just like her (face only, don't have that chest) But I must say Ashley looks more elegant, however, Holly looks sexier. I guess it all depended on the "feel" your trying to go for...They both look stunning in the dress, just in differt ways. Apples and Oranges.


I Think That Holly Is So Beautiful And Shes My Fave Girlfriend In The Show But She Looks Like Shes About To Fall Out Of This Dress. Plus It Doesnt Flatter Her Figure All That Well. I Dont Like Ashley All That Much But She Fills Out This Dress Nicely And Her Hair And Makeups Whimsical Feel Only Add To The Luxe Feel.


holly is so much hotter, ashleys okay.


i think ashley all the way holles tits are to big and fat soz holly u are so ugly though i love u ashley u rock luv ellie


me parese que alas dos le quedan super lindos esos vestidos,aunque le queda mas lindo a ashley


bueno es verdad sus festidos son muy iguales pero a ashley le queda mejor aunque soy admiradora de las 2 chicas y veo mansio playboy me gusta ese programa sigan asi chicas y tambien me gusta todo lo ke hace ashley la adoro