Those tears were NOT fake! I was there in the audience, close up...She struggled to keep hold of herself...her mother is saying that kelly's dad was abusing her and she had to leave...that means she left her baby with an abusive daddy...definitely something to be crying about.
Larry Says:
November 9th, 2007 1:20 AM
You bottom feeder "gossip news" parasites are such low life cynics that you can't believe someone could really have true emotions about going from absolutely nothing to achieving their wildest dreams. You're so detached from any real emotions yourselves that you no longer believe they exist in anyone. Sad for you. (FYI--Sadness is an emotion.)
R Williams Says:
November 9th, 2007 1:37 PM
If she was faking then she's the best actress since Meryl Streep and will have no problem making her new sit-com a huge success! I don't for one minute pretend to know this person but from all the stories I've seen, she's had it pretty rough and it seems at times her emotions get the best of her. I guess you'd call that what, oh I don't know, human! Oh by the way Doug, Proctologist is it? You're right she didn't win AI, didn't even make it to the finals, I believe, but all that means is she wasn't GIVEN a recording contract she had to EARN it.
JL Says:
November 11th, 2007 7:08 PM
Definitely planned. Conveniently made it through the song before her "breakdown." Anyone truly upset by lyrics wouldn't have made it through the song. All those who watched American Idol remember how well she played up the "ditzy blonde" act throughout the show, she can put on an act very well. As the old saying goes ... Everyone's got to get attention some way.
Cheryl Says:
November 11th, 2007 8:20 PM
DO NOT judge a person unless you have walked in their shoes. Kellie is a very talented artist. It is pretty obvious there are still jealous people among us.
RP Says:
November 12th, 2007 9:03 AM
People who say Kellie's tears are fake need to get a life! How can you be so ridiculous? She's been through tough times, and her emotions are very strong. They're real, people!
Billy Joe Says:
November 12th, 2007 3:28 PM
Tears or not... Who cares?!
This was after all the Country Music Awards... an ENTERTAINMENT show! Were you entertained? Were you moved? Did you enjoy the show?! Cuz I did! I watched this show because I love all the different genres of Country Music sharing one stage on one big night. This show is meant to be enjoyable... so enjoy and leave the girl alone. If she was moved to cry... then she is allowed to cry!
Personally, the show got me all revved up! I wanted more so I went over to http://www.lonestar925.com
Lone Star 92.5 is a station I am working with and they play everything from country to classic rock with hardly any commercials. Give it a try. :)
Did you check it? What do you think?
edfrienz Says:
November 14th, 2007 2:20 PM
Oh I do not think she was faking it. Everyone's personality is different and if you sang he song from your heart and had her experience you would probably shed a tear. It is better to lose a mother/father then for them to be out there but ignoring you....and oh those years when you need a Mother to talk to. I think it is sad and I think it was for real so hadn't she heart enough without anyone saying it is fake. I wish she was my daughter and I would love to give her some of what she missed for I have 2 great sons. I would love a daughter though and she is a good one to have. Hats off to you Kellie you are going to make it big and without your Mother.
Trixter Says:
November 15th, 2007 11:55 AM
She's real, If her cicumstances would have been different we may not have known kellie pickler as we now know her or maybe not at all, We all travel different roads to get to our destinations. finding forgiveness for her mother may be her best medicine yet, as her leaving her has put her in the spotlight through her emotions and causing her to become who she is today along with a great set of grandparents. keep on keeping on girl!
gr Says:
November 16th, 2007 12:07 PM
Who cares, it was a great performance. If they were fake, perhaps she has an acting career ahead of her.
mike Says:
November 16th, 2007 4:18 PM
Don't judge someone till you have been in their shoes. I am a man and i tear up when i hear that song because the same thing happened to me. Sometimes you just want to know why. Keep singing Kellie you are great.
KR Says:
November 18th, 2007 10:03 AM
Even though she has performed that song many times(crying) I think she was overwhelmed. SHE DID PERFORM ON EVERY ASPIRING COUNTRY ARTISTS DREAM...The CMA's is a big deal!! I'll admit, i DID NOT like Kelli on American Idol, but now, that she is an artist, i see her completely different. Proud of her for getting there without her mother! Way to go Pickler! You keep singing your song!
San Says:
November 21st, 2007 5:01 PM
CMA 2007Q? Who was gal who sang alone(Beautifully Too) Got standing ovation. camera didn't seem to pan in on her face too much. Appreciate a reply :)
Regards, San
Alex Says:
November 25th, 2007 4:48 PM
those were NOT fake tears, i have no idea what kind of loser would say that. she is really full of emotion, i mean wouldnt you be if you were abandoned and 19 years later your mother comes back on the news and makes like shes a saint? and she was not at all trying to take carries spotlight, in albermarle, nc we just arent those kind of people.
Mandy Says:
November 26th, 2007 1:40 AM
What a bunch of jerks! Unless you know what it is like to be without your own mothers as a child, then you have no right to judge her! Fake tears? Doubt it! And, not to mention, this was a big day for her... how many people get to preform at an award show like that?? Grow up!! I hope you don't teach your children these same qualities.
Walter Says:
December 1st, 2007 1:14 PM
I find this very interesting. There isn't one person commenting here that knows what her actual emotional state really was - some people do have the ability to MAKE themselves emotional and therefore in a way "fake" cry - and I've watched the clip and I will say this much, I'm not the kind of person to cry, but I got choked up and felt a little silly for doing so, but I wonder if maybe the song has that effect on her where she can't help but cry sometimes while singing it; don't have a clue if she has the ability to act on her emotions or if her emotions just get the best of her. I'm not into her music and don't really even like the song; it's a bit boring to me...but while watching her perform it also played on my emotions and still I don't have a clue and neither do those of you telling people that they are "Jerks" if they don't believe she was not faking; it almost makes you a jerk, because you only know what you think you know and only Pickler really knows her emotional state at the time. We can believe what we want, but I do agree with one poster that said it was all just entertainment and he was entertained...I was also and I still don't know.
Kim Says:
January 22nd, 2008 6:54 PM
Tears were not fake!!!!! If you listened to the song she struggled all the way through it.
Kassidy Says:
April 15th, 2008 5:36 PM
I agree these tears are not fake!! I have had a parent walk out on me and the song made me cry. When she breaks down the song is reflecting forgivness and for anyone who has ever had to fight the struggles this young lady has you know that forgivness is the HARDEST thing to achieve. The pain of not having a mother will never leave her no matter how much money she makes or how famous she will become. Kellie you keep your head up.. i love the song!!
Mack Says:
April 20th, 2008 6:36 PM
well, Kellie Pickler got on my nerves during the american idol season, but when i heard this, I automaticlly knew i was being 2 hard on her. I know love her though her lil thing about going 2 a spa scared me. I LOVE U KELLIE! HANG IN THERE!!!!!
mack Says:
April 20th, 2008 6:47 PM
ANYONE who thinkz kellies tears were fake, are people whos life is out of order! you do NOT know what its like 2 have your momma leave u and not come back. leave the gal alone, shes VERY talented, and never did a thing 2 u so just shutup about it, please!!!!! shes wonderful, I LOVE YA GIRL, KEEP ON SINGIN!!!!
Charlotte Says:
June 7th, 2008 6:08 PM
These tears are not fake. The best singers are those that take their experiences, put them into words and create a beautiful tune to compliment it. I am sure reality hit her. She was in front of all of her "idols" expressing the most deepest feelings to america about her shattered past. God Bless You, Kelli!
chelsea Says:
July 29th, 2008 6:01 AM
poor thing. Kelly kind of annoyse me, i hear shes as blonde as her hair but this.......this right here, is real. Shes in pain and you know what? I think she looked very beautiful when she cried and i think that made it that much better. Its a sad song thats made up of truth sang by the person singing it out to others. You have to realize everytime she sings that song, she re-lives what she is singing about. Can you imagine that? When singers get up on stage, you expect a steady performance and its pretty much always that way. But when a singer gets up there and sheds tears over what they are singing about, it makes your heart feel things towards that person, and realize how much the song actually sings. She may be in an expensive red gown and have that superstar shine that us normal people dont have, but when she cries, you realise that shes human too. Shes got feelings too, just like the rest of us.
cheryl vine Says:
September 10th, 2008 3:08 PM
kellie is just a person who has had a hard life and deserve all the fame she can get i do not believe that was a fake she has a lot of pain from what her mother did and she will be okay as she matures in her life and to make sure she will not do the same to her children. all the best to you kellie i adore you and have nothing but best wishes and much success.
marisa Says:
November 2nd, 2008 4:35 PM
i think that she is truly crying from the heart. i love her so much, i look up to her. Even her brother was crying so it had to of be real.
November 9th, 2007 12:57 AM
Those tears were NOT fake! I was there in the audience, close up...She struggled to keep hold of herself...her mother is saying that kelly's dad was abusing her and she had to leave...that means she left her baby with an abusive daddy...definitely something to be crying about.
November 9th, 2007 1:20 AM
You bottom feeder "gossip news" parasites are such low life cynics that you can't believe someone could really have true emotions about going from absolutely nothing to achieving their wildest dreams. You're so detached from any real emotions yourselves that you no longer believe they exist in anyone. Sad for you. (FYI--Sadness is an emotion.)
November 9th, 2007 1:37 PM
If she was faking then she's the best actress since Meryl Streep and will have no problem making her new sit-com a huge success! I don't for one minute pretend to know this person but from all the stories I've seen, she's had it pretty rough and it seems at times her emotions get the best of her. I guess you'd call that what, oh I don't know, human! Oh by the way Doug, Proctologist is it? You're right she didn't win AI, didn't even make it to the finals, I believe, but all that means is she wasn't GIVEN a recording contract she had to EARN it.
November 11th, 2007 7:08 PM
Definitely planned. Conveniently made it through the song before her "breakdown." Anyone truly upset by lyrics wouldn't have made it through the song. All those who watched American Idol remember how well she played up the "ditzy blonde" act throughout the show, she can put on an act very well. As the old saying goes ... Everyone's got to get attention some way.
November 11th, 2007 8:20 PM
DO NOT judge a person unless you have walked in their shoes. Kellie is a very talented artist. It is pretty obvious there are still jealous people among us.
November 12th, 2007 9:03 AM
People who say Kellie's tears are fake need to get a life! How can you be so ridiculous? She's been through tough times, and her emotions are very strong. They're real, people!
November 12th, 2007 3:28 PM
Tears or not... Who cares?!
This was after all the Country Music Awards... an ENTERTAINMENT show! Were you entertained? Were you moved? Did you enjoy the show?! Cuz I did! I watched this show because I love all the different genres of Country Music sharing one stage on one big night. This show is meant to be enjoyable... so enjoy and leave the girl alone. If she was moved to cry... then she is allowed to cry!
Personally, the show got me all revved up! I wanted more so I went over to http://www.lonestar925.com
Lone Star 92.5 is a station I am working with and they play everything from country to classic rock with hardly any commercials. Give it a try. :)
Did you check it? What do you think?
November 14th, 2007 2:20 PM
Oh I do not think she was faking it. Everyone's personality is different and if you sang he song from your heart and had her experience you would probably shed a tear. It is better to lose a mother/father then for them to be out there but ignoring you....and oh those years when you need a Mother to talk to. I think it is sad and I think it was for real so hadn't she heart enough without anyone saying it is fake. I wish she was my daughter and I would love to give her some of what she missed for I have 2 great sons. I would love a daughter though and she is a good one to have. Hats off to you Kellie you are going to make it big and without your Mother.
November 15th, 2007 11:55 AM
She's real, If her cicumstances would have been different we may not have known kellie pickler as we now know her or maybe not at all, We all travel different roads to get to our destinations. finding forgiveness for her mother may be her best medicine yet, as her leaving her has put her in the spotlight through her emotions and causing her to become who she is today along with a great set of grandparents. keep on keeping on girl!
November 16th, 2007 12:07 PM
Who cares, it was a great performance. If they were fake, perhaps she has an acting career ahead of her.
November 16th, 2007 4:18 PM
Don't judge someone till you have been in their shoes. I am a man and i tear up when i hear that song because the same thing happened to me. Sometimes you just want to know why. Keep singing Kellie you are great.
November 18th, 2007 10:03 AM
Even though she has performed that song many times(crying) I think she was overwhelmed. SHE DID PERFORM ON EVERY ASPIRING COUNTRY ARTISTS DREAM...The CMA's is a big deal!! I'll admit, i DID NOT like Kelli on American Idol, but now, that she is an artist, i see her completely different. Proud of her for getting there without her mother! Way to go Pickler! You keep singing your song!
November 21st, 2007 5:01 PM
CMA 2007Q? Who was gal who sang alone(Beautifully Too) Got standing ovation. camera didn't seem to pan in on her face too much. Appreciate a reply :)
Regards, San
November 25th, 2007 4:48 PM
those were NOT fake tears, i have no idea what kind of loser would say that. she is really full of emotion, i mean wouldnt you be if you were abandoned and 19 years later your mother comes back on the news and makes like shes a saint? and she was not at all trying to take carries spotlight, in albermarle, nc we just arent those kind of people.
November 26th, 2007 1:40 AM
What a bunch of jerks! Unless you know what it is like to be without your own mothers as a child, then you have no right to judge her! Fake tears? Doubt it! And, not to mention, this was a big day for her... how many people get to preform at an award show like that?? Grow up!! I hope you don't teach your children these same qualities.
December 1st, 2007 1:14 PM
I find this very interesting. There isn't one person commenting here that knows what her actual emotional state really was - some people do have the ability to MAKE themselves emotional and therefore in a way "fake" cry - and I've watched the clip and I will say this much, I'm not the kind of person to cry, but I got choked up and felt a little silly for doing so, but I wonder if maybe the song has that effect on her where she can't help but cry sometimes while singing it; don't have a clue if she has the ability to act on her emotions or if her emotions just get the best of her. I'm not into her music and don't really even like the song; it's a bit boring to me...but while watching her perform it also played on my emotions and still I don't have a clue and neither do those of you telling people that they are "Jerks" if they don't believe she was not faking; it almost makes you a jerk, because you only know what you think you know and only Pickler really knows her emotional state at the time. We can believe what we want, but I do agree with one poster that said it was all just entertainment and he was entertained...I was also and I still don't know.
January 22nd, 2008 6:54 PM
Tears were not fake!!!!! If you listened to the song she struggled all the way through it.
April 15th, 2008 5:36 PM
I agree these tears are not fake!! I have had a parent walk out on me and the song made me cry. When she breaks down the song is reflecting forgivness and for anyone who has ever had to fight the struggles this young lady has you know that forgivness is the HARDEST thing to achieve. The pain of not having a mother will never leave her no matter how much money she makes or how famous she will become. Kellie you keep your head up.. i love the song!!
April 20th, 2008 6:36 PM
well, Kellie Pickler got on my nerves during the american idol season, but when i heard this, I automaticlly knew i was being 2 hard on her. I know love her though her lil thing about going 2 a spa scared me. I LOVE U KELLIE! HANG IN THERE!!!!!
April 20th, 2008 6:47 PM
ANYONE who thinkz kellies tears were fake, are people whos life is out of order! you do NOT know what its like 2 have your momma leave u and not come back. leave the gal alone, shes VERY talented, and never did a thing 2 u so just shutup about it, please!!!!! shes wonderful, I LOVE YA GIRL, KEEP ON SINGIN!!!!
June 7th, 2008 6:08 PM
These tears are not fake. The best singers are those that take their experiences, put them into words and create a beautiful tune to compliment it. I am sure reality hit her. She was in front of all of her "idols" expressing the most deepest feelings to america about her shattered past. God Bless You, Kelli!
July 29th, 2008 6:01 AM
poor thing. Kelly kind of annoyse me, i hear shes as blonde as her hair but this.......this right here, is real. Shes in pain and you know what? I think she looked very beautiful when she cried and i think that made it that much better. Its a sad song thats made up of truth sang by the person singing it out to others. You have to realize everytime she sings that song, she re-lives what she is singing about. Can you imagine that? When singers get up on stage, you expect a steady performance and its pretty much always that way. But when a singer gets up there and sheds tears over what they are singing about, it makes your heart feel things towards that person, and realize how much the song actually sings. She may be in an expensive red gown and have that superstar shine that us normal people dont have, but when she cries, you realise that shes human too. Shes got feelings too, just like the rest of us.
September 10th, 2008 3:08 PM
kellie is just a person who has had a hard life and deserve all the fame she can get i do not believe that was a fake she has a lot of pain from what her mother did and she will be okay as she matures in her life and to make sure she will not do the same to her children. all the best to you kellie i adore you and have nothing but best wishes and much success.
November 2nd, 2008 4:35 PM
i think that she is truly crying from the heart. i love her so much, i look up to her. Even her brother was crying so it had to of be real.