Kellie Pickler Cries During Country Music Awards Performance: Sincere or Staged? Comments (Page 2)

34 Comments

26. Walter Says:
    December 1st, 2007 1:14 PM
    

    I find this very interesting. There isn't one person commenting here that knows what her actual emotional state really was - some people do have the ability to MAKE themselves emotional and therefore in a way "fake" cry - and I've watched the clip and I will say this much, I'm not the kind of person to cry, but I got choked up and felt a little silly for doing so, but I wonder if maybe the song has that effect on her where she can't help but cry sometimes while singing it; don't have a clue if she has the ability to act on her emotions or if her emotions just get the best of her. I'm not into her music and don't really even like the song; it's a bit boring to me...but while watching her perform it also played on my emotions and still I don't have a clue and neither do those of you telling people that they are "Jerks" if they don't believe she was not faking; it almost makes you a jerk, because you only know what you think you know and only Pickler really knows her emotional state at the time. We can believe what we want, but I do agree with one poster that said it was all just entertainment and he was entertained...I was also and I still don't know.

27. Kim Says:
    January 22nd, 2008 6:54 PM
    

    Tears were not fake!!!!! If you listened to the song she struggled all the way through it.

28. Kassidy Says:
    April 15th, 2008 5:36 PM
    

    I agree these tears are not fake!! I have had a parent walk out on me and the song made me cry. When she breaks down the song is reflecting forgivness and for anyone who has ever had to fight the struggles this young lady has you know that forgivness is the HARDEST thing to achieve. The pain of not having a mother will never leave her no matter how much money she makes or how famous she will become. Kellie you keep your head up.. i love the song!!

29. Mack Says:
    April 20th, 2008 6:36 PM
    

    well, Kellie Pickler got on my nerves during the american idol season, but when i heard this, I automaticlly knew i was being 2 hard on her. I know love her though her lil thing about going 2 a spa scared me. I LOVE U KELLIE! HANG IN THERE!!!!!

30. mack Says:
    April 20th, 2008 6:47 PM
    

    ANYONE who thinkz kellies tears were fake, are people whos life is out of order! you do NOT know what its like 2 have your momma leave u and not come back. leave the gal alone, shes VERY talented, and never did a thing 2 u so just shutup about it, please!!!!! shes wonderful, I LOVE YA GIRL, KEEP ON SINGIN!!!!

31. Charlotte Says:
    June 7th, 2008 6:08 PM
    

    These tears are not fake. The best singers are those that take their experiences, put them into words and create a beautiful tune to compliment it. I am sure reality hit her. She was in front of all of her "idols" expressing the most deepest feelings to america about her shattered past. God Bless You, Kelli!

32. chelsea Says:
    July 29th, 2008 6:01 AM
    

    poor thing. Kelly kind of annoyse me, i hear shes as blonde as her hair but this.......this right here, is real. Shes in pain and you know what? I think she looked very beautiful when she cried and i think that made it that much better. Its a sad song thats made up of truth sang by the person singing it out to others. You have to realize everytime she sings that song, she re-lives what she is singing about. Can you imagine that? When singers get up on stage, you expect a steady performance and its pretty much always that way. But when a singer gets up there and sheds tears over what they are singing about, it makes your heart feel things towards that person, and realize how much the song actually sings. She may be in an expensive red gown and have that superstar shine that us normal people dont have, but when she cries, you realise that shes human too. Shes got feelings too, just like the rest of us.

33. cheryl vine Says:
    September 10th, 2008 3:08 PM
    

    kellie is just a person who has had a hard life and deserve all the fame she can get i do not believe that was a fake she has a lot of pain from what her mother did and she will be okay as she matures in her life and to make sure she will not do the same to her children. all the best to you kellie i adore you and have nothing but best wishes and much success.

34. marisa Says:
    November 2nd, 2008 4:35 PM
    

    i think that she is truly crying from the heart. i love her so much, i look up to her. Even her brother was crying so it had to of be real.