The Hollywood Gossip Readers Speak: Asia Nitollano is Talented, a Bad Mother, Other Things

by at . Comments

Readers of The Hollywood Gossip are not afraid to voice their opinions. And we thank each and every one of you for that. Some of the issues you feel the strongest about are:

Greg Laswell rules.

Simon Monjack sucks.

One celebrity about whom voices are mixed, however, is new Pussycat Dolls member Asia Nitollano. Many of you think she's a great addition to the group. Others lament that Melissa was not chosen as winner of the reality competition that crowned the newest Doll.

While you decide on which side you stand - and controversy swirls over whether or not Asia will ever sing with the group - read a few of the reader comments left by those that have already made up their minds...

KALIMAH writes: I think that it is jacked up what they are saying about Asia. She won that contest fair and square. The girl has talent and she worked so hard. She deserves a record deal rather it be with the pussy cat dolls or solo. You dont fulfill someone's dream then take it away without a valid excuse.

TAMARA writes: all i got to say is that maybe they don't think shes fits becaause she looks and acts like the lead singer… i honestly think she'd be a better leader then [Nicole Scherzinger]…

supeRr-cOokiie writes: MELISSA SHOULD'VE WON! although she did look abit like nicole. melissa was hell good. i think she is a pussy cat doll! i didnt like asia! she was so mean! and chelsea was alright. but melissa should've won! PCD is just.. not cool anymore. lol.

KRISTIE writes: asia is a bad mother if she leave her daughter to go on tour she has a responsability now its not all about her!!!!!1 i feel sorry for her daughter having a mother like her. i wont be buying any albums if she is in them!!!!!!

* The Hollywood Gossip note: Wow, that's harsh. Wonder how Kristie feels about the fact that Britney Spears hasn't seen Jayden James in two or six months.

SARA MAY writes: I think that Melissa R should have won, she is a better singer and dancer, and she sims to come along with other girls better. I have also read that in the next season they are looking for members to form a new group, inspired by the pussycat dolls.

JEFF LOVES ASIA writes: Asia was the best pick for the Dolls, shes hot shes a great singer and that girl can dance. Chelsea tried to be too much like Christina Aguilera, if she wants to be her go sing back up with her or something. and Melissa R. was a good singer but she didn't make a good doll. Asia's got that sparkle.

So there you have it, celebrity gossip lovers. A mixed bag of opinions if there ever were any.

Write in and let us know where you stand on Asia. While you're at it, feel free to chime in on the Holly Madison vs. Carmella DeCesare nude debate, as well.

Tags:
Avatar

Asia was a stupid ugly insulted that judged people -_- even though i'm judging her right now. She started arguments first with calling people fake. If she was that good, where is she now? She's not in pcd or making a good use of her time. Grow up asia.

Avatar

I <3 Asia
she was smart not joinging the group. ok in the psd, the only person anyone knows in nicole, no one even knows the other girls names, and whats the point of being it that group if nicole was leaving any way to start her solo job
stop hating on asia, you guys are just jelous

Avatar

I truely believe Melissa R has talent an shouldve have won, and Asia might have sparkle but the girl cant sing!! But then again there is also lots of so called singerrrrs out there in the music business that cant sing either..Robin should've created a group with Melissa R, Chelsea and Asia instead of coming out with "Girlicious"!!!!

Avatar

correction: Van Dammes were not necessarily bad parents, they just got caught up in their lifestyle and someone knew about it and caught them while they indulged.

Avatar

Susan Smith=drowned her kids, stayed home w/them all day
Andrea Yates=drowned her kids, stayed home w/them all day
Van Dammes=swingers, child murdered while parents partied in their basement These are bad mothers, and the list goes on. Watch what you say.......

Avatar

April, I could not have said it better myself. I guess I must be a bad mother bcause I work (2) jobs to make ends meet so that my sons can eat, drink, have a clean, safe place to live, have clothes, shoes, toys. What makes a good mother? Stop judging, you never know what you tomorrow brings.

Avatar

GET OVER IT ASIA WON!!!!! BECAUSE SHE GOT A BIG BREAK MAKES HER A BAD MOTHER? HOW MANY ACTORS, SINGERS, AND OTHER PERSONS THAT ARE IN THE PUBLIC EYE THAT HAVE CHILDREN ARE BAD PARENTS? GIVE THE GIRL A BREAK, SHE WON, SHE OBVIOUSLY DESERVED IT. IF MELISSA HAS THE TALENT SOMEBODY CAUGHT THAT AND WILL GIVE HER AN OPPORTUNITY, MAYBE SOMETHING THAT SHE HAD NOT IMAGINED. INSTEAD OF TRYING TO BLOCK THIS GIRLS SHINE, JUST GIVE HER PROPS. IT'S NOT EVERYDAY SOMEONE IS GIVEN A CHANCE OF A LIFETIME. WHEN YOU GET YOUR CHANCE HOW WOULD LIKE FOR PEOPLE SAYING HOW YOU DIDNT DESERVE IT AND SOMEONE ELSE WAS THE BETTER PERSON AND YOU KNOW THAT IT WAS SOMETHNG THAT REALLY YOU LONGED AND DREAMED FOR?. DON'T TAKE THAT AWAY FROM HER, LET HER GET HER'S IT'S ENOUGH OUT THERE FOR EVERYBODY........CONGRATS ASIA, STAY GROUNDED AND KNOW THAT YOU ARE MAKING A BETTER LIFE FOR YOU AND YOUR DAUGHTER.

Avatar

Asia was the best choice , she may not of had the best voice, but she was the sexiest, & greatest dancer of all, and lets face it thats what they were looking for, she was not going to be lead singer of the PCD.Now I hope she didnt make a mistake about not joining to go solo.I believe she should have joined at least for a year then go solo.
But in any case I hope she makes it big time, she deserves it, because I really loved her in the competition.

Avatar

i put if asia didnt win i would want it to be melissa s or chelsea...obviously i ment mellisa R..i hate melissa S..although she is canadian like me lol

Avatar

one person i DID NOT like was melissa S she is rude and not as good as she thinks she is. chelsea melissa r are alot better than her. if asia didnt win i would want it to be melissa s or chealsa..deffinatly not melissa S she is a b**** in my books