Kelly out of her zone what? That's bull. Kelly is still the same sweet, dorky, down to girl from Texas that we me back in 2002. Kelly is by far the most down to earth celeb out there. *now i'm not saying Carrie isn't, both are sweet girls". :)

Carrie, by a mile. I loved Kelly when she was on idol, but she has gone out of her zone. Carrie is still the same sweet, down-to-earth person she was on season 4.

Kelly is the best 4ever.I'm bored listening carrie's voice.But I feel refreshing listening kelly's voice

always kelly n forever

to rulz, so what if kelly clarkson is a quest judge on AI 9. i feel really sorry for kelly coz carrie had guested on the show a lot more. including her voice was used for the farewell song for the contestants("home sweet home") suck on that KELLY FAT CLARKSON!!) and carrie underwood has more AWARDS than kelly. FYI.