American Idol Eye Candy: Kelly Clarkson vs. Carrie Underwood Comments (Page 4)
146 Comments
megs714
June 7th, 2008 3:03 PM
Kelly hasn't made a public appearance lately since she's chunked up. Carrie Underwood will be on this season of Nashville Star sometime... and Taylor Swift will be in the premiere on Monday. NBC at 9 pm bitchez!
cg
June 6th, 2008 1:06 PM
Kelly is not fat, and someone on the KC Express said they saw Kel recently and she didn't look fat at all, she looked fit. And her voice is not worn out and she is not a horrible singer. The last time you saw her sing live on tv must have been back at the Thanksgiving Day football game which I said she just finished a tour, she sings non-stop, plus I think she was sick too. Back in April when she sang at the Papal Youth Rally she kicked a$$ like always. If she was horrible why did the Pope choose her to Ave Maria infront of him...um maybe because the girl rocks. Just wait for her fourth album to come out this fall.
Simon
June 5th, 2008 11:23 PM
Carrie can sing. Kelly's voice is so worn out that she is a horrible singer. Listen to her recent performance on live tv. Move over, there's a new superstar in town and her name is Ms. Underwood!
Carrie is easy on the eyes as well, Kelly is overweight. Lose some of that at girl!
cg
June 5th, 2008 6:45 PM
Kelly's my favorite, I like Carrie but Kelly's voice is so much more amazing. I don't think there is nothing that this girl can sing. Who cares if Carrie has won more awards than Kelly that shouldn't matter. Besides there more country awards than there are awards Kelly can be up for. Kelly is a million times better live than Carrie, she is one of the few singers who sound way better live than on a cd and that's because the girl is amazing. I don't how you could ever get tired of hearing Kelly. I'm no saying Kelly is fat she's normal and healthy, and at least she has some meat on her bones maybe Kelly should give some of her so called "flab" to Carrie. How can Carrie be more successful than Kelly if Kelly has sold the most world-wide and practically everybody in the whole entire world has heard of her and it's not because of Idol. There are people in some parts of the world who don't know who Carrie is. Also Kelly is not ugly. And I also think that Kelly could kick Carrie's a$$ in coun
Ed IN CINCINNATI
May 17th, 2008 4:27 PM
carrie underwwod by far. kelly is good to :)
amanda
May 15th, 2008 4:11 PM
KELLLLLLLLY CLARKSON
amy_lee
May 14th, 2008 1:19 PM
kelly has got personality. and sorry.. but carrie doesn't. no offence, but kelly sings live much better than carrie. carry is good too, but I think kelly is one of the most powerful artists we have now. I don't think that people say that kelly is better cause she sings pop. she was born to sing, and her voice... so strong... some people say that she screams her songs.. it's not true. she has so powerful voice, so she writes that strong and powerful songs.
i dunno why I felt in love with her voice so much. I really like her for being just herself. she didn't changed her heart. and I think that she always puts her soul, every time she sings, every concert she is. inside, she's the same natural girl.
and that is her power. power of dreams? of course. I'm so glad that AI made her dreams come true.
go kelly! <3<3<3
and best for carrie fans :).
darla
May 14th, 2008 1:08 PM
kelly. kelly, kelly.
simply amazing. she has so powerful voice...!! carrie is ok, talented too... but to me, kelly blows all that plastic singers away.
foreverandever.
marleman
May 1st, 2008 6:28 PM
they are both great in their music, but what maybe carrie fans didnt know is that kelly´s is famous around the world not because she was an american idol winner or the original idol, kelly is well known worldwide because her music "breakaway" even most of the countries didnt know about her live in idols, they know her because os her music. That will be a big difference with Carrie that by the way is great witn country, that carrie is to conmited with idols that is easyly identify her with idols. In Usa, Kelly is known as the original idol, the first idol, or the former idol champ, or whatever, the american sweetheart, but arond the world she is a superstar worlwide singer/artist, where carrie nobody knows her. anotehr differences is that kelly has the guts to fight for her music when carrie is follow what others say to her but that is wright for her because maybe she doesnt have enough courage to do what kelly did. Another difference is that maybe carrie and kely are great in what the
joanie
April 23rd, 2008 8:32 PM
kelly is NOT fat shes curvy you guys are waaaaaay tooo judgemental and BUTTHEADS! aretha franklin was big but she was successful. KELLY ALL THE WAY CARRRIE CANT TOUCH KELLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! kelly has an amazing voice and personality and shes beautiful and more successful and versatile!
Hazel
April 23rd, 2008 8:27 PM
KELLY CLARKSON FOR SURE! I LOVE KELLY WITH ALL MY HEART SHE'S MY FAV SINGER IN THE WORLD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HAPPY BIRTHDAY KELLY! IF YOU ARE A KELLY FAN JOIN KCKELLYVILLE.COM
Ana
April 23rd, 2008 4:27 PM
Carrie. I love her voice. The only reason people say Kelly is better is because she sings pop and that is a more popular genre. I love Kelly too, but she isn't good live and that is kind of what a great singer is: someone who can sing at any moment, any song and sound amazing.
Amanda
April 23rd, 2008 4:22 PM
Carrie.
@l£x
April 14th, 2008 9:25 PM
Okay, I'm a Kelly fan all the wayyy but you won't see me writting spiteful comments about Carrie coz I'm not tht kind of person who enjoys putting other ppl dwn. But the thing is it doesn't matter how fat people call Kelly she'll still have the voice of an angel. Also who/what sez she has to be thin? if that was the case then she'd be a model or w.e.
GO KELLY!!! =D
Bonnie
April 9th, 2008 10:22 PM
Kelly Clarkson is my favorite singer of all time!!!
maimai
April 6th, 2008 4:10 PM
Well, it's a hard but i'm going with kelly clarkson because yea it's like carrie has the voice but kelly has the personality.
I judge people by there personlality not by there clothes or the voice or by anything else.
Hugo
April 6th, 2008 3:05 AM
Carrie Underwood!! is MUCH BETTER THAN KELLY. CARRIE'S VOICE IS SUCH AMAZING!! HER SONGS ARE TOTALLY AMAZING!! KELLY IS GREAT BUT SHE IS TO MUCH POP. CARRIE IS COUNTRY, POP AND GOSPEL!! SHE'S EVERYTHING!!
CARRIE ROCKS!!!
Anonymous
April 1st, 2008 5:02 AM
Kelly Clarkson. I hear Carrie's quite a bitch.
amh62772
March 19th, 2008 7:08 PM
Kelly all the way. Carrie has a good voice, but Kelly has more range and can do it all.
chaneen
March 18th, 2008 10:45 AM
by the way..even just by watching Idol Season 1 people can actually see that Kelly is not just a great singer, she's a natural performer too. Love her "Stuff Like That There"..her vocal was flawless, beautiful, yet she managed to keep it fun and interesting and EFFORTLESS (with facial expressions, gestues etc. and even with very little movement, she made it very special). I;m sorry but for me it's Kelly all the way
chaneen
March 18th, 2008 10:37 AM
i think people who chose Carrie over Kelly might not have watched Idol Season 1. That's the only reason I can think of. Kelly's voice is beautiful and soothing..Carrie's is good too, but I found it to be tiring after a while
waky
March 16th, 2008 11:04 AM
kelly can sing any kind of music ...try carrie if she can sing pop rock.. she sang well in country... but to be a good preformer and singer like mariah, celine, you need to be flexible in singing different type of music right. Like what carrie did in idol she always stick on the country side... even in the finals. Not like kelly she sang from pop, rnb,soul, and even rock songs thats a great VOCAL artist...Most of the people listen to pop, rnb rather than country... but i do like carrie to...but kelly is the best and the original IDOL
Pris
February 28th, 2008 5:56 AM
Okay folks, first of all they are both great. As of 2008, FYI:
Kelly:
Thankful is 2x platinum, 3 million US, 900,000+ internationally
Breakaway is 6x platinum, 6 million US, 11+ million worldwide
My December is platinum in US, 1.8+ million internationally (and voted in the top 5 BEST - doesn't mean selling but rather sounding albums of 2007 by Billboard Magazine's reader fans
Total albums sold almost 20 million worldwide and still counting (and going strong); Kelly has won over 60 awards across the board including 2 grammys, and her nominations alone are at least double her won awards. She is not just an American idol but she is an international star known very well in Europe, Asia and Australia
Carrie:
Some Hearts is 7x platinum; that's almost 7 million in US and Canada
Carnival Ride is 2x platinum
Total albums sold is 11 million worldwide; Carrie has won 37 awards to date, plus add about 1/3 more for total nominations.
Granted keep in mind that Kelly started a coupl
Tyler
February 26th, 2008 2:36 AM
CARRIE all the way!!!!!!! Sold 7 million on her first album!!!! Won two grammys with it .... Kelly sold about a quarter of Carries sales and also no grammys. Kelly's second album was succesful but Carries second album has all ready beat Kelly's in the 17 th week with 2 million sales. Now you may have an opinon of who you like better, but statically Carrie has proven to be the better idol!!!!!!!! GO CARRIE!!!!!!!
lainey
February 25th, 2008 10:00 PM
Oh and I want to mention something that I mentioned on another website. Which is I think people are choosing Carrie because she is competition to Kelly and they want Kelly to look bad and not win. It's weird too because majority of the people do not like country music and all of a sudden you have all these people saying, go carrie!! you rock!! you better than kelly!! but is she really? Are you saying country music is better than pop/rock? LoL cause if you are, then no comment =/
June 7th, 2008 3:03 PM
Kelly hasn't made a public appearance lately since she's chunked up. Carrie Underwood will be on this season of Nashville Star sometime... and Taylor Swift will be in the premiere on Monday. NBC at 9 pm bitchez!
June 6th, 2008 1:06 PM
Kelly is not fat, and someone on the KC Express said they saw Kel recently and she didn't look fat at all, she looked fit. And her voice is not worn out and she is not a horrible singer. The last time you saw her sing live on tv must have been back at the Thanksgiving Day football game which I said she just finished a tour, she sings non-stop, plus I think she was sick too. Back in April when she sang at the Papal Youth Rally she kicked a$$ like always. If she was horrible why did the Pope choose her to Ave Maria infront of him...um maybe because the girl rocks. Just wait for her fourth album to come out this fall.
June 5th, 2008 11:23 PM
Carrie can sing. Kelly's voice is so worn out that she is a horrible singer. Listen to her recent performance on live tv. Move over, there's a new superstar in town and her name is Ms. Underwood!
Carrie is easy on the eyes as well, Kelly is overweight. Lose some of that at girl!
June 5th, 2008 6:45 PM
Kelly's my favorite, I like Carrie but Kelly's voice is so much more amazing. I don't think there is nothing that this girl can sing. Who cares if Carrie has won more awards than Kelly that shouldn't matter. Besides there more country awards than there are awards Kelly can be up for. Kelly is a million times better live than Carrie, she is one of the few singers who sound way better live than on a cd and that's because the girl is amazing. I don't how you could ever get tired of hearing Kelly. I'm no saying Kelly is fat she's normal and healthy, and at least she has some meat on her bones maybe Kelly should give some of her so called "flab" to Carrie. How can Carrie be more successful than Kelly if Kelly has sold the most world-wide and practically everybody in the whole entire world has heard of her and it's not because of Idol. There are people in some parts of the world who don't know who Carrie is. Also Kelly is not ugly. And I also think that Kelly could kick Carrie's a$$ in coun
May 17th, 2008 4:27 PM
carrie underwwod by far. kelly is good to :)
May 15th, 2008 4:11 PM
KELLLLLLLLY CLARKSON
May 14th, 2008 1:19 PM
kelly has got personality. and sorry.. but carrie doesn't. no offence, but kelly sings live much better than carrie. carry is good too, but I think kelly is one of the most powerful artists we have now. I don't think that people say that kelly is better cause she sings pop. she was born to sing, and her voice... so strong... some people say that she screams her songs.. it's not true. she has so powerful voice, so she writes that strong and powerful songs.
i dunno why I felt in love with her voice so much. I really like her for being just herself. she didn't changed her heart. and I think that she always puts her soul, every time she sings, every concert she is. inside, she's the same natural girl.
and that is her power. power of dreams? of course. I'm so glad that AI made her dreams come true.
go kelly! <3<3<3
and best for carrie fans :).
May 14th, 2008 1:08 PM
kelly. kelly, kelly.
simply amazing. she has so powerful voice...!! carrie is ok, talented too... but to me, kelly blows all that plastic singers away.
foreverandever.
May 1st, 2008 6:28 PM
they are both great in their music, but what maybe carrie fans didnt know is that kelly´s is famous around the world not because she was an american idol winner or the original idol, kelly is well known worldwide because her music "breakaway" even most of the countries didnt know about her live in idols, they know her because os her music. That will be a big difference with Carrie that by the way is great witn country, that carrie is to conmited with idols that is easyly identify her with idols. In Usa, Kelly is known as the original idol, the first idol, or the former idol champ, or whatever, the american sweetheart, but arond the world she is a superstar worlwide singer/artist, where carrie nobody knows her. anotehr differences is that kelly has the guts to fight for her music when carrie is follow what others say to her but that is wright for her because maybe she doesnt have enough courage to do what kelly did. Another difference is that maybe carrie and kely are great in what the
April 23rd, 2008 8:32 PM
kelly is NOT fat shes curvy you guys are waaaaaay tooo judgemental and BUTTHEADS! aretha franklin was big but she was successful. KELLY ALL THE WAY CARRRIE CANT TOUCH KELLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! kelly has an amazing voice and personality and shes beautiful and more successful and versatile!
April 23rd, 2008 8:27 PM
KELLY CLARKSON FOR SURE! I LOVE KELLY WITH ALL MY HEART SHE'S MY FAV SINGER IN THE WORLD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HAPPY BIRTHDAY KELLY! IF YOU ARE A KELLY FAN JOIN KCKELLYVILLE.COM
April 23rd, 2008 4:27 PM
Carrie. I love her voice. The only reason people say Kelly is better is because she sings pop and that is a more popular genre. I love Kelly too, but she isn't good live and that is kind of what a great singer is: someone who can sing at any moment, any song and sound amazing.
April 23rd, 2008 4:22 PM
Carrie.
April 14th, 2008 9:25 PM
Okay, I'm a Kelly fan all the wayyy but you won't see me writting spiteful comments about Carrie coz I'm not tht kind of person who enjoys putting other ppl dwn. But the thing is it doesn't matter how fat people call Kelly she'll still have the voice of an angel. Also who/what sez she has to be thin? if that was the case then she'd be a model or w.e.
GO KELLY!!! =D
April 9th, 2008 10:22 PM
Kelly Clarkson is my favorite singer of all time!!!
April 6th, 2008 4:10 PM
Well, it's a hard but i'm going with kelly clarkson because yea it's like carrie has the voice but kelly has the personality.
I judge people by there personlality not by there clothes or the voice or by anything else.
April 6th, 2008 3:05 AM
Carrie Underwood!! is MUCH BETTER THAN KELLY. CARRIE'S VOICE IS SUCH AMAZING!! HER SONGS ARE TOTALLY AMAZING!! KELLY IS GREAT BUT SHE IS TO MUCH POP. CARRIE IS COUNTRY, POP AND GOSPEL!! SHE'S EVERYTHING!!
CARRIE ROCKS!!!
April 1st, 2008 5:02 AM
Kelly Clarkson. I hear Carrie's quite a bitch.
March 19th, 2008 7:08 PM
Kelly all the way. Carrie has a good voice, but Kelly has more range and can do it all.
March 18th, 2008 10:45 AM
by the way..even just by watching Idol Season 1 people can actually see that Kelly is not just a great singer, she's a natural performer too. Love her "Stuff Like That There"..her vocal was flawless, beautiful, yet she managed to keep it fun and interesting and EFFORTLESS (with facial expressions, gestues etc. and even with very little movement, she made it very special). I;m sorry but for me it's Kelly all the way
March 18th, 2008 10:37 AM
i think people who chose Carrie over Kelly might not have watched Idol Season 1. That's the only reason I can think of. Kelly's voice is beautiful and soothing..Carrie's is good too, but I found it to be tiring after a while
March 16th, 2008 11:04 AM
kelly can sing any kind of music ...try carrie if she can sing pop rock.. she sang well in country... but to be a good preformer and singer like mariah, celine, you need to be flexible in singing different type of music right. Like what carrie did in idol she always stick on the country side... even in the finals. Not like kelly she sang from pop, rnb,soul, and even rock songs thats a great VOCAL artist...Most of the people listen to pop, rnb rather than country... but i do like carrie to...but kelly is the best and the original IDOL
February 28th, 2008 5:56 AM
Okay folks, first of all they are both great. As of 2008, FYI:
Kelly:
Thankful is 2x platinum, 3 million US, 900,000+ internationally
Breakaway is 6x platinum, 6 million US, 11+ million worldwide
My December is platinum in US, 1.8+ million internationally (and voted in the top 5 BEST - doesn't mean selling but rather sounding albums of 2007 by Billboard Magazine's reader fans
Total albums sold almost 20 million worldwide and still counting (and going strong); Kelly has won over 60 awards across the board including 2 grammys, and her nominations alone are at least double her won awards. She is not just an American idol but she is an international star known very well in Europe, Asia and Australia
Carrie:
Some Hearts is 7x platinum; that's almost 7 million in US and Canada
Carnival Ride is 2x platinum
Total albums sold is 11 million worldwide; Carrie has won 37 awards to date, plus add about 1/3 more for total nominations.
Granted keep in mind that Kelly started a coupl
February 26th, 2008 2:36 AM
CARRIE all the way!!!!!!! Sold 7 million on her first album!!!! Won two grammys with it .... Kelly sold about a quarter of Carries sales and also no grammys. Kelly's second album was succesful but Carries second album has all ready beat Kelly's in the 17 th week with 2 million sales. Now you may have an opinon of who you like better, but statically Carrie has proven to be the better idol!!!!!!!! GO CARRIE!!!!!!!
February 25th, 2008 10:00 PM
Oh and I want to mention something that I mentioned on another website. Which is I think people are choosing Carrie because she is competition to Kelly and they want Kelly to look bad and not win. It's weird too because majority of the people do not like country music and all of a sudden you have all these people saying, go carrie!! you rock!! you better than kelly!! but is she really? Are you saying country music is better than pop/rock? LoL cause if you are, then no comment =/