American Idol Eye Candy: Kelly Clarkson vs. Carrie Underwood

by at . Comments

Before a new American Idol gets crowned in two weeks, we have a pressing question:

Who is your favorite American Idol winner of all-time?

Carrie on Idol

We'll assume that Fantasia, Ruben Studdard and Taylor Hicks aren't even in the running. And, remember, Chris Daughtry and Clay Aiken didn't actually win their respective seasons.

So this leaves two options for fans of the FOX reality show: original Idol victor, Kelly Clarkson? Or season four's champion, Carrie Underwood?

Each has picked up Grammy Awards, although only Underwood has picked up an All-Pro NFL quarterback. It's a close call.

Perhaps fans will want to wait for the new Kelly Clarkson album to come out in July before making a decision. But if you have a preference right now, let us know.

And, yes, we wish Katharine McPhee had won last year, too. Go blame The Soul Patrol for that one.

Tags: ,

carrie underwood roxs my soxs


Carrie by a mile! It's not even close!


kelly of course.i like carrie too but i think kelly is more versatile.carrie,s song is just too familiar to dont 4get to remember me is just same as breakaway.but im not blaming carrie for just the producer that copycat the song.


kelly clarksons clearly better Kelly of course


kelly is the best and everyone knows it,, carrie underwood is nothin to kelly! no one try 2 convince me cuz its true!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! kelly vs carrie ???? kelly wins without a doubt


Well Ive Got Say Carrie Shes Absoultly Fantastic And HAs Brought A Whole New World To The Music Buisness!!
I Certinaly For One Didnt Listen To Country Before She Came Along !!
She Has So many Fans Here In The Uk It Unbelieveable!!


there both good, but i have to say that carrie is better. her voice is the best!


I love both, but Carrie's voice live is so much better than Kelly's. Carrie has the voice, and Kelly has the personality.


kelly! she has the better voice, the better performances, and the better everything else. and kelly is so versatile. she can do touching ballad performances (Grammy's) or pumping anthem songs (VMA's) Kelly is the best and always will be. And, Kelly won her Grammy's from Breakaway, which was more of Kelly and less of her girl next door 'Idol' image. Carrie got a Grammy from her debut album, which is always an American Idol image CD. And after all, you don't hear Steve Carrell shouting Carrie's name in a movie.


tough. Kelly Clarkson has been here longer, but I do enjoy the sound of Carrie underwoods voice more than hers. This is REALLY close to me. I don't know who I would say. Since Kelly is getting a little washed up, and you havent really heard about her now a days, I would have to say Carrie