We had our doubts. Don't get us wrong, Scarlett Johansson is quite the looker. But so are many other ladies.

Take a look at this Jessica Biel picture, for instance. That's not unhot.

Previous winner, Angelina Jolie, could also have taken back the sexy crown; while some on our staff think underdog Kristin Davis deserved the honor.

After seeing this shot of Johansson from her spread in Allure magazine, however, we give in. We give up. Even these Kristen Cavallari pictures can't compete with the exposed Scarlett below: