You are not signed in. Login or Register

Hilary Duff: Goin' Goth? Comments (Page 3)

73 Comments

« Previous
Next »
1 2 3 4
  1. pak Says:

    Hilary rock she has a great voice and her acting is realy great love her new cd by the way ashlee you can talk i'm sure that you can't sing so don't come and teel that hilary duff can't sing

  2. courtnee Says:

    Hilary duff is not goth or punk EMO or wat eles u think she a girl and she is very cool and im her bigest fan i love hilary so please write me an e-mail at prettycourts@hotmail.com bye love courtrnee x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0 XxxxXxxxX

  3. missy Says:

    It takes more then black hair to go goth. Amy Lee, she was goth, Hilary Duff isn't going goth, shes not wearing all black, besides, it's a way of life, it's MY way of life!

  4. Kaaaay Says:

    I hate Hilary Duff, and the only reason I'm on this site is because I serched "I hate Hilary Duff" so yeah. And by the way the darker her hair goes the worst it gets, sorry that just my OPINION. I don't care if it's for a movie I'm just saying. And shes famous because of her show Lizzie Mcquire, her parents prob. made her go into the showbiz when she was younger so now she's a celeb. Her voice isn't anything special such as: Mariah Carey or Beyonce or anyone. And I bet anyone could act. Celebs get WAY WAY WAY over-paid. Mhmm heres 1 million dollars for smiling, now get over here so we can do your make-up and fix your nails. WOW BABY HARD LIFE EH? Who gives a **** about paparatzi (can't spell) and "No Private Life" if they really wanted to. They could use all there money to get plastic surgery and move to flipping Hawaii. Jeeze stop feeling sorry for these people, there nothing without us "Fans" And why do we like them so much? There not saving our lives.. what about doctors and teachers.. we don't scream or cry of joy and happiness when they touch your shoulder do you? Like really, think about it.

  5. gaby Says:

    hi my name is gaby and i loooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooove hilary duff shes the best
    i wish i could meat her ,so this is my msn hiba_pink@hotmail.fr
    see ya

  6. Emily Says:

    Sorry Hilary but your black hair is realy bad!, please come back to your beautiful blond hair like Lizzie Mcguires!, you look realy stupid now, i'm just telling the truth!

  7. iii Says:

    LOL DAMN Y YALL GOTTA TALK ABOUT HILARY DUFF LIKE THAT ? LOL YO LET ME GET SOMETHING STRAIGHT 2 YALL G@Y PEOPLE IN THIS WORLD !! LOL 1ST ABOVE HAIR COLOR DONT MATTER !! 2ND ? DONT HATE !! 3RD ? SHE AINT NO DAMN GOTH ? !! R U F***ING KIDDING ME ? .....

  8. seliinn Says:

    ben hilary duffa aşığğıımm onu çoq sefiorm odam posterleriyle dolu kim ne derse desin hilaryy 1 numaraa

  9. kayla Says:

    by the way the one person who said hilary duff is stupid you are. cuz she is her own person let her be who she wonts to be and you dont have to des her because she is her own person.you no what i dont realy know hilary duff but she comes off to be a nice person and you are just juging her.

  10. MAYRA Says:

    hola como estas ustedes son identicas pueden benir ha peru porfis eso es mi sueño y k me canten para mi santo sus canciones las dos juntas mi santo es 5 de nobienbre ...... ojala k bengan les dejo mi direccion jr ayacucho 1454 la perla alta callao

  11. Kaylafrie Says:

    Hey hailey i love your fashion it is so hot hey send me a messsge will ya. my Yahoo
    is kaylafrie@yahoo.com if you want i would love to add ya on my Yahoo messager got to go See ya hailey !

  12. Irene Says:

    i think hilary looks best in auburn cuz it kind of matches her skin colour. Black is nice 2 but it kind of makes her pale.

  13. shannon Says:

    I love Hilary Duff but i like her better with her blonde hair. She has fare skin so the lighter colour looks better. I do think that she might be going a bit goth and she is getting too skinny, she needs to regain some of her weight, she looked good in raise your voice and cheaper by the dozen

  14. Name (required) Says:

    I think that Hilary will always be beautiful whatever colour she dyes her hair but chocolate locks suit her best (1st picture). Hilary's my role model and i love her so much! i have her perfume and i want all her movies!

  15. Mariana Almeida Says:

    eu nao sei se voces vao entender a lingua brasileira... eu sou Mariana... adoro hilary duff( i'm brasilian and like hilary duff).... adorei esse espacinho aki...... vou tentar dizer algo q sei em ingles... :
    Hilary is the best.. i'm love she

  16. linoyaa Says:

    i love hilary so much stay who you are don't chang you are beautiful pleas send me a masseg linoysadon1@walla.com
    love you

  17. vivian Says:

    i love hil nadie te gana no hagas caso de nada ere especial y hermosa

  18. hilary Says:

    i liked better the brown..the dark doesnt suits her well, but like u said, the inside is the important, and i like how she sings..die to your natural hilary

  19. lujain Says:

    i luv hilary duff with any look but the only thing that black hair dosen't mean you are going gothic ...even my hair is long black hair and i put a dark eyeliner and many ppl say that i look like evanescence and it dosen't means i am gothic ...

  20. nini Says:

    YOU GUYSZ KNOE THOSE R CONTACS THEY ARENT THE REAL THING..BECAUSE I REMEBER IN LIZZIE MCGUIRE SHE HAD DARK BROWN EYES ND YOU CAN TELL THOSE ARE CONTAC'S!!!

  21. nini Says:

    I HATE HILARY DUFF 2 SHE IS SUCH A B****!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ND UGLY TOO!!!!

  22. lore Says:

    hello !! i'm spanish , and looooooooooooveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee you hilary (as friend) you are very beautiful and your songs are very cool !!

  23. Shan Says:

    none of us know hillary duff personally so theres no way anyone can say shes a goth, wannabe or a bad person or whatever. you dont have to like music or her hair color but i think its rude and immature to judge someone you've never even had a conversation with. Anyways tho i think she looks beautiful with any hair but the dark is my favorite.

  24. holly Says:

    i think she looks good either way hoever agrees with me type 10

  25. Goth should be considered a legitimate culture Says:

    What is it that causes you all to assume that modifying one particular aspect of your appearance automatically justifies that the term Goth is appropriate when applied to yourself? I am a Goth and I personally agree that the dark color accentuates her features, yet I can't possibly comprehend why EVERYTHING black is considered Goth...could someone enlighten me?

    Adolescents do an excellent job of further confounding what it is that constitutes the proper application of the term Goth. It is ultimately becoming simply a teenage label reserved for anything darker in color or in nature. These are appalling, absolutely unwarranted generalizations. It is as if Goth is a trend of sorts, although perhaps I should distribute some information to those deficient in knowledge about the CULTURE, rather than the scene or phase. Who knows? Maybe then you will be satiated with accurate knowledge pertaining to a form of Goth not found much in high school, and does not involve the Ostro/VisiGoth variety.

    I had posted this on a website besides this one, and this is merely a section of what I had written. Here it is:

    "Goths are a cultural minority which emphasizes pacifism, tolerance, introspection, spirituality, morality, intellectualism, aesthetics, individualism, creativity, high-brow culture, philosophy, as well as various beliefs, values, opinions, and ideas in response to such matters. Goths often detest unreasonable social conventions to an intense degree, and are typically characterized as indignant and may engage in 'insubordinate' conduct rather than remain in accordance with standards of which are regarded as inconceivable to abide by, although it is evidently to prevent injustice on their behalf when supposed restrictions can easily be obnubilated with oppression.

    Goth will continue to exist when this ludicrous social and music scene ceases. We are the minority, yet we shall function as preservers of an immortal culture. We provide the foundation despite the fact that we do not appear to maintain influence. You must retain the fact that we are here, and we are dedicated and quite conservative (although not in relation to non-Gothic conservatives). When the youth are no longer engaged in Goth, it shall remain anyhow.

    Also, Goths consider the prevaling standards of beauty within the predominant current of thought to be absolutely appalling. As a result, there is no 'ugly.' All body types are accepted as well as other physical differences.

    Sexuality is often a topic of concern for Goths. Gays, lesbians, bisexuals, transgendered people, those who practice BDSM as well as simply standard sex...are all accepted.

    In society, a darker mindset is discouraged, although Goths understand that what is supposedly 'insane' behavior is actually the result of supressed dark thoughts. Goths assume that if darkness is expressed through art or poetry or there are simply more discussions regarding it, there will be no pent up rage or frustration which eventually results in destructive outbursts. This does not necessarily imply that Goths merely concentrate on their darker nature, they simply emphasize it more, especially through aesthetics and creative pursuits.

    I personally believe the more unconventional you appear to be, the more dedicated you are. Goth is certainly not about moderation, after all. Thick makeup, piercings, and colored hair are, in my opinion, very beautiful as well as convey a willingness to be Gothic despite persecution and hardships. Conservative Goths are usually always quite 'extreme' in appearance and being this way also promotes their self-expression, while moderation restricts it to merely being 'edgy,' and, if they are young, perhaps 'cool.'

    And here is another example of Goth, written exclusively by that of myself as well.

    "I am a Goth who cannot establish claims of an advanced age, although you cannot disregard of the Elder Goths, as they provide the foundation of the culture, which is unfortunately quite deficient in those who are willing to preserve of it. I became a Goth and modified my appearance merely 10 years ago, and I am quite content with this manner of being. It is assumed that discrimination against Goths is only a trivial and humorous matter, although it is certainly not, and a genuine Goth would remain a Goth for the duration of his or her existence, and continue to maintain the appearance as well. I cannot possibly comprehend why it is that Goth is perceived of as some sort of personal choice, rather than a source of enlightenment that people are actually devoted to, and that Goths, on the condition that they wish to cease experiencing prejudice and intolerance, should simply revert to their previous beliefs and discard of their "Gothdom," despite the fact that Goth is similiar to a religion in numerous respects, and is definitely a valid culture, although unfortunately is not very well received by the Dominant Culture and is therefore perceived as something done in jest and insincerity a.k.a. a 'phase.' When Goths complain they are simply considered 'angsty' rather than possessing an actual reason to experience such emotions in relation to the circumstances. Haven't the majority of non-Goths ever conceived of why it is that despite an unreasonable amount of discrimination that Goths confront daily they continue to espouse the beliefs and dress in black and apply 'unconventional' makeup? I am cognizant of the fact that we are not of your kind. We do not conform to identical or even similar values, yet we simply desire peace. We are a pacifistic community and therefore could never invoke this unjust treatment upon ourselves. My intention is not to convert you to my ways - I simply desire your patience in reading this. I wish to merit your company and walk amongst your kind without the lingering shame concerning who I am. I wish to accomplish what you accomplish, to simply arrive within a public location without being ridiculed. I myself possess numerous aspirations that I am unfortunately unable to achieve due to the conservative society declining my offers of contributing to civilization. Yet it is not I who shuns them in return, as certain Goths do, rather, I strive for the common good. I assist others when my assistance is needed. I recognize morals and principals, and attempt to do what is ethical in any given situation. I may perceive of such matters in an alternate manner to society, yet this desire is what all human beings share to a certain extend. It is inherent within us all, some moreso than others. Please, my friends, listen to me. I must request something of you and I shall remain grateful until I cease existing and perhaps beyond that. Distribute the information pertaining to Goth being a genuine culture. Support me in my attempts to produce increasing awareness of this matter which is significant to me. I thank you all for your time."

    And this cannot be forgotten, now can it?

    "The perception of Goth as some sort of social scene apparently does not do it justice. Goth is an anomaly of what it should be, as it is lacking foundation - as I had mentioned previously. The "Elder Goths" are often in their 20s, and it appears as though Goth is merely an extension of their youth that they are unwilling to abandon, which absolutely appalls me. The entire concept of 'youth subcultures' appalls me as well. If you integrate yourself into a culture or subculture for a purpose, why should a person's age automatically disqualify such a person from participating? Especially when there are millions of people involved worldwide rather than it being confined to a specific high school (which therefore WOULD meet the requirements essential to being considered an adolescent-oriented subculture). There is nothing specifically youth-oriented about Goth. Goths are not expected to experience antipathy towards 'preps' (who most often detest such a label and do not wish to be associated with it) and celebrate teen angst, as certain non-Goths would contend. The Gothic genre of music itself does not convey to others the inherent lack of maturity of the enthusiasts. Therefore it should be assumed that Goth is reserved for simply those who identify with it, irrespective of age. Goth is certainly not exactly what would be considered a religion in precise terms, although it could DEFINATELY be a culture, belief system, and spiritual path. For the majority of Goths who do not place emphasis on committment, there are also quite a few who do, including myself, yet these are seldomly acknowledged, which is simply awful. I am passionate as an adherent of this specific belief system, and therefore I rigidly advocate the addition of standards which permit no deviation. Therefore only the most devoted of adherents will possess the honor with which to proclaim themselves as adherents. Goths may be tolerant of others, although this is no reason to obnubilate what the term Goth is intended to refer to. After all, people are considered 'poseurs' anyhow, despite the lack of definitive standards, and as a result they should therefore be able to understand WHY others are referencing them in such a disparaging manner. The imposition of standards would eliminate confusion, although it would require the assistance of the indispensible members of the Gothic community, rather than the efforts of one person, and that is what would appear to be quite challenging, especially since Goths are distributed throughout the world, rather than within a distinct location, and also because Goths are individuals who are capable of making well-formulated decisions, implying that their ideas and my ideas may not come into accord. They may perhaps be utterly opposed to the mere consideration of Goth becoming established. This is what I am dreadful of."

    Now, would anyone be interested in assisting me in promoting the Gothic Culture as it should be? Also, if you wish to adhere to this vision of the culture you may certainly do so. After all, we desire those who shall preserve of Goth and espouse the beliefs which adequately represent it.

« Previous
Next »
1 2 3 4

Leave a Comment

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.

Name:

E-Mail:

Remember My Info

Your Comments
No need for HTML formatting, we insert line breaks. Allowed tags: <b> <i> <a>

Featured Posts

Chris Brown Reacts to Rihanna 20/20 interview
Chris Brown Reacts to Rihanna 20/20 interview
This Just In: Britney Spears Lip-Syncs!
This Just In: Britney Spears Lip-Syncs!
Miley Cyrus: Jay Z Who?!?
Miley Cyrus: Jay Z Who?!?

Featured Pics

Celebrities

Britney Spears
Britney Spears
Kim Kardashian
Kim Kardashian
Lauren Conrad
Lauren Conrad
Heidi Montag
Heidi Montag
Zac Efron
Zac Efron
Vanessa Hudgens
Vanessa Hudgens
Miley Cyrus
Miley Cyrus
Spencer Pratt
Spencer Pratt
Robert Pattinson
Robert Pattinson
Adam Lambert
Adam Lambert
Taylor Lautner
Taylor Lautner
Taylor Swift
Taylor Swift
Roxy Olin
Roxy Olin
Khloe Kardashian
Khloe Kardashian
Levi Johnston
Levi Johnston
Hailey Glassman
Hailey Glassman