Photo Finish: Jessica Simpson vs. Vanessa Minnillo

Who's copying whom?

Considering the fact that Vanessa Minnillo got Jessica Simpson's sloppy seconds as far as men were concerned, it's safe to assume which hottie came up with the following outfit first:

Jess or Vaness?

We think Jessica takes the beautiful cake. What do YOU think?



38 Comments

Next »
1 2
  1. Skeptical Chic Says:

    both of them look like they rolled out of a sheet and made it into a dress

  2. Ashlee Simpson Says:

    Jessica looks so much better in that then the other girl

  3. polaiune Says:

    Vanessa looks better. She looks more natural and carefree. Everything about Jessica just looks fake.

  4. andrea 19 agosto de 2006 en 01:13 Says:

    la verdad yo digo que que mala onda de vanessa osea es ovio! que jessica es mucho mas bonita y lo unico que vanessa tiene es que una quita novios no esta tan fea pero eso no se le hace a una amiga ¿no creen?

  5. valerie Says:

    Jessica by far looks better.

  6. Carolyn Cldwell Says:

    Vanessa will soon be an over the hill wet back while Jessica will be this thriving young beauty.
    Jessica is very smart, business savvy and very classy. I feel Nick is just using Vanessa but his true love will always be Jess. Everybody wants them back together, but Jessica married too young, hopefully one day she will see the light.
    Love you Jessica, you are my mentor for being a lady !!

    Dallas Texas Girl !!!

  7. jilldtv Says:

    take it from somone who knows them both, jessica cheated on him and joe simpson is a bigger bitch than both of them.

  8. Ary Says:

    ma siete tutti dislessici su questo sito???
    non ce nè uno che scriva più di 2 parole attaccate giuste...
    per tutti voi ignoranti: più meglio non si può dire....
    ma imparate a parlare prima di commentare su un sito...che vi sputtanate e basta....veramente...

  9. ann Says:

    jessica...smart?
    blah...blah...blah.....

  10. Kay Says:

    haha jessica is smart? what the hell are you talking about? Classy?!?! hahahahahha Wow you must be an idiot for having her as a youre "mentor". She's dumb as f*@k and as classy as a cheap hooker. Oh i get it, you must be a stripper and/or hooker.

  11. Kristine Says:

    Vanessa. I just lost respect for Jessica. A public affair? Yeah, she REaLLY loved Nick...

  12. Linda Says:

    Just you watch. To her core Jessica will never recover from her loss of Nick Lachey. The pain has not yet even begun. How sad. She could've had it all. She has set herself on a track of negativity for life.

  13. Name (required) Says:

    jessica is a dumb blond idiot - big mouth and greedy with money... as a matter of fact she became famous cuz of N. Lachey...

  14. melissa cabot Says:

    jessica i think should call nick lachey because you loved him and he loved you to he needs to know that so tell him on the phone get thse message e-mail me back my is NYCgal24fl@ol.com

  15. Rick Penny Says:

    Well all i can say is Jessica is a Beautiful girl , but Vanessa -Lordy-Lordy-Lordy Haven must a missing an Angel because Vanessa is here on Earth with us ...

  16. Ty Says:

    Jessica is very photogenic and hot but theres no more to her than that. looks can get old if they dont have the personality i would never get sick of looking at vannessa

  17. B. Says:

    Vanessa is beautiful. Far more beautiful then Jessica. Jessica is totally fake! Her lips are fake, she's ugly without makeup on! Vanessa is way prettier. Jessica is trashy, always has been! She cheated on Nick then leaves him treats him like crap and now she wants people to feel sorry for her because she wants him back???? WTF? Vanessa is classy, gorgeous, sexy as hell, and is a lady. Jessica Simpson is an ugly, cheating, lying *ss b*tch and for you people calling her smart??? No wonder you think she's smart cause you're just as dumb as her! At least that explains why you think she looks better. People liking Jessica is the only reason why her music sells and the fact that she's dumb enough to dress slutty to get her music to sell, you really think people buy her music for her voice??? GET REAL. Her voice isn't even good, it's all right and probably sucks without all the studio equiptment. but I know people who sing wayyyy better than her...I can't believe she's in the music business. and for the dumb B*tch that said "Dallas texas girl" I bet the only reason your dumb *ss likes her because YOU'RE from texas, you dumb *ss! LMAO!!

  18. Mag. Says:

    Nick Lachey found himself a gorgeous babe! She is so HOT! Jessica Simpson is alright, she's average, but Vanessa is beautiful, smart, sexy, and CLASSY! Nick Lachey is better off without her! He deserves someone who will love him and appreciate him. Jessica never appreciated him, she's a spoiled little sh*t whose a slut. She played herself by leaving Nick. She's a loser!

  19. Tony Says:

    JESSICA SIMPSON IS NOT HOT!!!!! Vanessa is BANGIN!! Nick Lachey would be a fool to leave Vanessa for Jessica which he won't do cause Jessica is a SLUUUUT!! Jessica should leave him alone cause she's not worthy of him. He's a great catch! And her family is nuts!! Her father really thought that slutty bikini music video she did was "christian" like???? yeah, I bet you thinking your daughter sleeping around is "christian" like too, huh?! stupid idiot. that's why your daughter is so dumb now....and the comment made by "B." I totally agree!!!

  20. AMY Says:

    I was a big fan of Jessica until she turned into a slut. I never really liked her voice but it was some of her songs that I liked. They were catchy. Jessica is pretty But to be honest, Vanessa is hotter, NO QUESTION. And she does look horrible without makeup...she's not naturally beautiful....Vanessa is.

  21. JS Says:

    TO ALL THE HATERS.... do not talk s&*% about Jessica, you do not know what really happened in the relationship maybe he cheated or maybe she cheated whatever happened is there business and no one could judge, but in reality think about it if she cheated on nick why was nick trying to get her back? a man that has been cheated on would have to much pride. Also, Jeassica is not all that in the head but she does have a good start and is a business woman. Let me ask you haters something? How much money are you making? don't talk S*&% about other people accomplishments and wealth.

  22. DAISY Says:

    I LIKE VANESSA BETTER...JESSICA'S GOOD LOOKING & EVERYTHING TOO...BUT I LIKED JESSICA BETTER WHEN SHE WAS W/ NICK...THEY WERE CUTE TOGETHER...W/O HIM...SHE KINDA TURNED ME OFF ...B'COZ IT'S NOT THE SWEET GIRL WE SAW ON "NEWLY WEDS" ANYMORE...I GET THIS STRONG FEELING THAT SHE CHEATED ON HIM...HEY...MAYBE SOMEWAY DURING THE COURSE OF THEIR RELATIONSHIP...HE MAY HAVE ENDED UP CHEATING TOO...BUT PROBABLY NOT...B'COZ MOST LIKELY SHE CHEATED FIRST...& CAUSED THE RELATIONSHIP TO GET ALL MESSED UP...& MESSED HIM UP TOO...ANY HOW...I JUST THINK THAT VANESSA IS BETTER FOR NICK...THEY LOOK MORE IN SYNC W/ EACHOTHER...I KNOW ALL WE SEE IS MAGAZINE PICS & ARTICLES...BUT SOMETIMES BODY LANGUAGE...& OTHER STUFF...YOU CAN REALLY READ INTO...WHEN I THINK OF NICK NOW...W/ VANESSA...I THINK OF HIM AS A BETTER MAN W/ MORE CONFIDENCE...& A NICE...HOT...GIRLFRIEND TO MATCH...AS AN EQUAL...ANYWAY...IT WOULD BE NICE TO SEE THEM END UP TOGETHER...W/ A COMMITTMENT... IE MARRIAGE...& EVEN A BABY...THEY WOULD MAKE THE CUTEST LITTLE BABIES...SORRY JESSICA...I THINK U REALLY FUCKED UP!

  23. prettyG Says:

    Well, I guess splitting is better than staying with someone you don't want to be with. So sad that she gets all the negative media while Nick is the one dishing dirt on her. *sniff*

  24. belle Says:

    vanessa is hot!!! Vanessa looks more smarter lol... I just cant stand watching or looking at jessica's face.....specially that newly weddz...i think her mouth is just fucked up..thats all i can say.

  25. nikki Says:

    I like Jessica better, but i think vanessa looks better in the picture though.
    I was soo sad when i heard that jessica and nick werent together anymore, and now he's with vanessa, she's pretty too, and i love her on TRL, but i just like jessica better than her, i love jesscia's music and i think both jessica and vanessa are beautiful and smart, but for some reason i still think jessica is the better girl.

Next »
1 2

Leave a Comment

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.

Name:

E-Mail:

Your Comments
No need for HTML formatting, we insert line breaks. Allowed tags: <b> <i> <a>