This is a tough one. Does the public believe universally despised Lindsay Lohan or complete unknown Harry Judd?

While the drummer for McFly claims he had a fling with the underweight acress, Lohan's rep is blasting the story as a publicity stunt. Judd had a cameo in the box office bomb, Just My Luck, and said Lindsay flirted with a few members of the band. They all went to a night club where she singled out 20-year-old Judd.

"Then she said, ‘Kiss me.' I was really nervous, I can tell you, because she's so super successful and talented. I thought, ‘This is awesome," Judd told the London Daily Mail. "Then she invited me back to her hotel, I left at eight the next morning.'"

That's a lot of Parcheesy! For about a year, Judd has denied buzz that the two had a fling, but a single on the group's new album is rumored to be about her. One line of the song "Please, Please, Lindsay, Please!" goes: "You love yourself more than you love me."

"He's using these lies for publicity," Lohan's rep, Leslie Sloane, said. "It's convenient how he's making up these stories when he has an album coming out."

Oh, really, Ms. Sloane? Sort of like it's convenient that your client is a worthless piece of spoiled trash?!?